Rail quiz (2)All the platforms
Can we find a National Rail station in London with every number of platforms from 1 to 20? spoiler: no we can't, but how close can we get?
n.b. Any National Rail station will do, including Overground or Elizabeth line.
n.b. We're only counting National Rail platforms, not tube platforms.
1) Emerson Park* 2) City Thameslink 3) Gordon Hill 4) Raynes Park 5) Hayes & Harlington* 6) 7) 8) Orpington 9) 10)
Railwatch (2)the shuttliest shuttle - the Bromley North branch
London has very few proper branch lines where separate trains shuttle back and forth to connect to the main network. There's the Liberty line between Romford and Upminster, also the GWR line running from Greenford to West Ealing. But shorter still is the spur line from Grove Park to Bromley North, a journey of less than two miles timetabled to take just five minutes, which is thus the shuttliest shuttle of all. It's a tale in three parts...
Grove Park
As the South Eastern Main Line zips through Grove Park, a completely separate platform serves solely to divert a few souls on the short hop to Bromley North. Things weren't always this way, the line used to have direct services to central London until 1990, after which a brief shuttle was deemed the better way to go. The mainline's now full to capacity so things won't change, but it's an inauspicious end for a commuter line opened in 1878 with such high hopes. Platform 1 is so far off-piste that if you arrive via the ticket hall a long suspended passageway stretches over the unused tracks, most unusual, whereas if you come from a connecting train the footbridge is more central. The timetable allows four minutes to interchange, which is great when it works and a right pain when it doesn't, as yesterday when my train from Lewisham was delayed and I had to wait 28 minutes for the next half-hour shuttle.
The platform was built for trains twice the length, hence the sign warning not you to bother using the furthest half. Facilities are fairly spartan, three seats tops, but if things go to plan nobody has to wait on the platform at all. The way the off-peak timetable works is that the train spends half of every 30-minute cycle standing here so you can simply hop aboard, the driver taking all the time in the world to walk from one end of the train to the other. At peak times trains run every 20 minutes so events speed up a little, and in excellent news the rush hour frequency is about to increase to every 15 minutes from mid-December (perhaps requiring the driver to dash). This timetable change will also see the reintroduction of Sunday services after perhaps decades without, as the powers that be finally start taking this branch line seriously.
→ off we go → bearing off south → 20mph on the curve → up to 30mph afterwards → the backs of lots of houses → a low embankment → allotments → recreation ground → people playing tennis → dipping down into a cutting → underneath Plaistow Lane → three minutes flat
Sundridge Park
This is the sleepy intermediate station, and nice enough it could almost be a country halt. Sundridge Park sits in a bit of a cutting with old road bridges at each end, and is again plainly too long for the trains that now stop here. Access is via a quaint trellis footbridge from a similarly charming ticket hall, although you can dodge the latter by walking straight past. The small upper room has a smart wooden bench, also several pot plants, also a shelf of books to borrow, also black and white photos of old trains, also a small exhibition of paintings by a local artist. The ticket office is open for 6½ hours a day, which seems utterly ridiculous at one of London's 20 least used stations, but the sole member of staff does also get to sweep up leaves on the platform once the 'rush' has died down.
The station's named after Sundridge Park, once the local stately home, now a golf course. It should perhaps be named after the local village which is Plaistow, indeed for the first 16 years it was, then they decided two London stations with the same name was silly. A smart row of shops sells nice things just outside should you ever visit, along with a turrety pub called The Crown. There may however be a flood of visitors here soon because the neighbouring terrace includes David Bowie's childhood home. He lived at 4 Plaistow Grove between the ages of 8 and 20, so this is proper formative, hence the Heritage of London Trust have bought the Jones's former cottage with the intention of opening it to the public. But neighbours in this quiet street aren't happy, also the planning application was withdrawn last month for additional tweaks, so all's not yet Hunky Dory.
→ off we go again → emerge from cutting → a very long fully-topiared hedge → metal footbridge → loads of parked buses → hang on how are we at the next station already?
Bromley North
It's ridiculous, Bromley North is less than half a mile from Sundridge Park, indeed the ends of the platforms aren't even 400m apart. It is thus really walkable which is another reason this railway line is massively underused. Arrive at the back of the train and the station looks quite bleak, a massively unnecessary expanse of island platform, only one side of which gets used. Those in the know thus always sit up front close to the exit, also the central canopy keeps you dry here should it be chucking it down. The driver currently has five minutes to change ends, allowing Bromleyfolk time to dash aboard, but when the new timetable starts there'll only be two minutes at peak times so good luck with that.
Beyond the rear wall is a large concourse bounded by faded retail units. Peter Morris Coins & Medals is closed this week, that's why it's quiet, whereas Grounded Brothers called in the bailiffs last year so no more Saturday brunch or tasting menus there. The main exit is down a tall airy ticket hall, ridiculously overblown for current passenger numbers, indeed Bromley North was somehow London's 21st least used station last year. And yet once again a Southeastern operative waits behind a window to sell you a ticket, this for a budget-busting 71 hours a week. There is a bit of a wow moment if you turn back to look at the station facade after exiting, given it almost resembles a classical edifice built to worship a god called SOUTHERN RAILWAY. The scale made sense when commuting to the City looked to be the future, but today it's just a portal to London's shuttliest shuttle, so fingers crossed it attracts a few more passengers once the timetable improves.
Rail geek (2)the steepest gradient
Which railway line in London has the steepest gradient? Apparently it's here.
This is the western approach to Farringdon station as a train to Sutton strains up the incline. This has a gradient of 1:29 which is incredibly steep for a railway. It's steep because the Thameslink line has to duck beneath the Metropolitan line and up the other side via Clerkenwell No. 1 Tunnel. It's steep because the Underground came first, this rail line appearing three years later. It's steep because space for construction on the edge of the City of London was extremely limited. And I know it's 1 in 29 because it says so on page 28 of the Network Rail Infrastructure Limited Network Statement 2024. I hadn't previously registered quite how steep this incline is, but if you stop and look even the far end of the platform is already tipping down.
And also here.
This is the climb out of City Thameslink towards Blackfriars through the site of the former Ludgate Hill station. This is also 1:29, this because trains have to climb from a station underground to a station on a bridge in the space of 300m. A third 1:29 can be found just north of City Thameslink, but that's inside the Snow Hill Tunnel which is why passengers never notice. I'm told this section is 64m long, whereas the Clerkenwell climb is 80m and the ascent to Blackfriars is 241m, making that the longest of the 1:29 gradients. I found thisdata on a website called railwaydata.co.uk but only because I knew where to look, there isn't one long database of all the gradients in London. There may be steeper somewhere else, indeed the NRIL Network Statement says "short extent gradients up to 1:25 occur in very specific locations", but that could be anywhere in the country.
For reference, the NRIL Network Statement says "gradients on the main line network may be as steep as 1 in 37", also "short extent gradients up to 1:25 occur in very specific locations". For reference, the steepest gradient on the Underground is generally accepted to be 1:28, this while climbing out of Bow Road station on the way to Bromley-by-Bow. But the steepest gradient on National Rail in London is 1:29, this in three separate locations on Thameslink between St Pancras and Blackfriars, unless any of you can convince us otherwise.
Rail geek (1)non-TfL stations
London has over 600 stations, but if you strip out those with TfL services how many are left? All 272 tube stations have to go, also 77 Overground stations, also Crossrail stations, also DLR stations, also tram stops, and by my calculations that leaves just 171. These are stations where the only way to depart is via a National Rail service, likely at a higher fare, and frequencies may not be that great either. Examples include Brentford, Bromley South, Carshalton and Crews Hill. But where are they?
This map shows how many non-TfL stations lie north and south of the Thames.
That's a very disproportionate spread, especially given the north side is larger than the south. North London has 60% of the area but only 30% of the non-TfL stations, while South London has 40% of the area but only 70% of the non-TfL stations. That's because the tube smothered central London first, then mostly spread north of the river, leaving most of south London for 'ordinary' railways to service instead. Part of the issue was geology - it was easier to tunnel north - but the vast majority of London's railways are above ground so it's not just about that.
Even greater disparities can be seen if you divide London into four parts. I drew lines centred on Trafalgar Square and counted the number of non-TfL stations in each quadrant.
By far the most non-TfL stations are in the southeast quadrant, an amazing 46% of the total (52 of which are operated by Southeastern). Another 33% of London's non-TfL stations are in the southwest quadrant (35 of which are operated by South Western). This leaves less than a quarter in the two northern quadrants. Least rail-heavy of all is the northwest quadrant with just 15 non-TfL stations - four Chilterns, the Greenford branch, Thameslink and half the lines out of Moorgate. The northeast's measly 22 comprises the remaining Moorgate services plus the Lea Valley line plus three c2c stations, everything else in the area being tube, DLR, Overground or Elizabeth line.
It's quite stark when you see who gets TfL train services and who doesn't, with the southern half of the capital especially deficient. It isn't truly Transport for London, when it comes to rail it's mostly Transport for North London, and until the Overground spreads its tentacles further south very little is likely to change.
Railwatch (1)Random station - BARNES
How better to kick off a week of rail-related content than with a visit to a randomly-selected London station? The non-TfL station that came out of my chancebucket is Barnes, a South Western station just beyond Putney. Here are ten things that are quite interesting about Barnes, over and above the fact it has platforms and trains.
1) Barnes station opened in 1846. The Tudor-Gothic ticket office built by architect John Thomas Emmett still stands beside platform 1, a fine building with eight chimneys, but is now a private home and office base. There is still a ticket office but it's in a small cabin at the tip of platforms 2 and 3 where the member of staff tends to dispense more advice than tickets. Amazingly the ticket office is still open for 42 hours a week, even three hours on a Sunday (whereas the last tube ticket offices closed 11 years ago).
2) Barnes has four platforms, one on each side and an island in the middle. Usually only platforms 1 and 3 are used (1 towards Waterloo, 3 towards Richmond and Hounslow). Things are different on Sundays however, so different that signs all around the station have to distinguish between Sunday and non-Sunday use. These advise those heading to Waterloo to use platform 2 on Sundays and platform 1 for the rest of the week, this because Sunday trains come from Woking rather than Weybridge. That said while I was at the station yesterday I saw trains using all four platforms, so it's not always as rigid as these unusual signs imply.
3) Barnes gained step-free access early last year thanks to £8m and three lifts halfway down the platform. The brickwork in the lift towers echoes the brickwork in the old station building, if you turn and look. The road across the station has never been step-free so if you're patient there is now a way to get from one side to the other via platforms 1 and 4.
4) The alleyway alongside platform 1 has recently been painted with a long colourful mural celebrating Barnes landmarks and local wildlife. It was designed by two local artists in conjunction with schools and other community groups. Queen are depicted because they recorded at Olympic Studios in Church Road, kingfishers appear because the London Wetland Centre is up the road and The Tiger Who Came To Tea is shown because Judith Kerr wrote the book in her three-storey Barnes terrace where she lived from 1962 to 2019.
5) The nearest place of interest, alas, is a memorial to Marc Bolan alongside Queen's Ride where he crashed his car and died in 1977, two weeks short of his 30th birthday. The shrubbery shrine contains a bust of Marc, all sorts of trinkets and flowers, plus a noticeboard where fans can leave messages for the T Rex singer. The latest stash of laminated messages is from a fan called Kalmiyh who sadly can't spell so the impact of her tribute "Hiros Come And Hiros Go" is somewhat diminished, "forevemore".
6) I don't know what litter gets dumped in the newspaper bins round your way, but here I spotted a packet of cigarettes and a small bottle of Pinot Grigio.
7) Barnes station might more appropriately be called Barnes Common because it's in the middle of it, not especially close to many houses. Hurrah that the common was never built on, but it does mean most Barnes and Roehampton residents approach via paths rather than roads which doesn't necessarily feel safe after dark.
8) Strategically the most important thing about Barnes station is that it's situated just before the tracks split left for Richmond or right for Hounslow. Left gets a lot more traffic, including all the fast trains rushing through towards Windsor or Reading. You can easily see the junction from the bridge by the entrance.
9) Railwaywise the most exciting thing about Barnes is that the split means there are two level crossings on Vine Road, just west of the station. They're only 60 steps apart, I measured it, and the barriers act independently of each other. No footbridges have been provided so you can get stuck for several minutes on one side or the other or in the middle, in which case the only way out is through the recreation ground. Everything's run remotely these days but a large operations room remains between the tracks, its windows now boarded up.
10) The twin Barnes level crossings have inspired a really useful local website called barnescrossings.org which shows whether the twin barriers on Vine Road are up or down or just about to close. It updates in real time and includes a graphic showing expected closures over the next 30 minutes so you can time your passage appropriately. Even if you're not in Barnes you can sit at home and feel connected to comings and goings at this fine zone 3 station, safe in the knowledge you don't have to walk home from it.
It's time once again to devote a week to London transport related content. I've brought you eleventubeweeks, an Overground week and even a cablecar week, but this time I'm going totally non-tubular and bringing you a rail week. Every post will be about National Rail stations and railways in the capital, ideally those that don't have any TfL services. As usual I'll be churning out three posts a day so come back regularly to discover why building stations is hard, the worst rail replacement bus, the shuttliest shuttle, how to count platforms, the busiest station that isn't on the tube map and of course a daily quiz. Let's make tracks...
London's newest bus route 10: Newington Green to Battersea Bridge South Side Location: central London Length of journey: 7 miles, 60 minutes Last ran: 23 November 2018 Reborn: 14 November 2026
Here's an unusual resurrection, of a bus number if not a bus route. The number 10 was first used on a longstanding route between Victoria and Abridge in Essex, then reused for buses between Archway and Hammersmith before being retired in 2018. Yesterday it came back for a third time as TfL took the opportunity to chop up a central London corridor, creating three routes where previously there were two.
Formerly...
• Route 38 ran from Clapton Pond to Angel to Hyde Park Corner to Victoria.
• Route 19 ran from Finsbury Park to Angel to Hyde Park Corner to Battersea Bridge.
• The overlap between Angel and Hyde Park Corner had been in place for 92 years.
As of yesterday...
• Route 38 was curtailed at Holborn, losing everything to the south.
• Route 19 was diverted to Victoria to cover the loss of the 38.
• Route 10 is new and terminates at Battersea Bridge to cover the loss of the 19.
Here's my map.
TfL have also made a map which you can see at bus stops but not online. It's actually quite a good map for once, with a clear and simple description of the changes alongside, but I can only link to a crummy photo because whoever runs the TfL website detests maps.
You might be thinking how does this save money? Well...
» Routes 19 and 38 have both been cut by two miles. This means fewer vehicles are needed (and it's more reliable).
» Route 38 was previously one of London's most frequent routes with a bus every 5 minutes. It's been cut to every 10.
» Route 38 was previously operated by a fleet of 36 buses (only route 18 needed more). It's been cut to 16.
» Route 19 was previously operated by a fleet of 21 buses. It's been cut to 17.
» Route 10 has a fleet of 21 buses. This is fewer than the 24 buses removed by cutting routes 19 and 38.
» ...and there are still 18 buses an hour between Angel and Holborn (previously it was 12 38s and six 19s, now it's six on each route).
How has the changeover gone? Tiles: spot on. Timetables: hit and miss. Bus blinds: in the week before changeover all the 38s said N38 on the front. TfL website: all routes incorrect (10 error message, 19 unchanged, 38 unchanged). Electronic systems: major fkup. On Friday I boarded a number 19 which said Chelsea Beaufort Street on the front, Battersea Bridge in the announcements and 19 to Victoria on the internal display (one day too early). On Saturday I boarded a number 10 which said Battersea Bridge on the front and 10 to Victoria on the internal display. All the countdown displays at bus stops were also displaying 10 to Victoria. The 10 doesn't go to Victoria (and hasn't since 1988). Total fkedup Victoria obsession.
Let's go for a ride, north to south
Newington Green's on the Islington/Hackney borders and is very much somewhere Time Out would give a thumbs up. Resting 10s park on the south side, thus the first stop is round the corner at Beresford Road. The 10's not really needed here, three other routes also run the mile and a half down to Angel, thus everyone waiting piles about the 73 instead and the 10 pulls in behind to little fanfare. I'm surprised by the absence of bus-spotters, normally Day 1 of a new route acts like a teenage enthusiast magnet. One stop later we've crossed the Overground and one stop later we're on Essex Road, already joining up with the 38 which we'll now shadow for the next 2½ miles. We're also starting to fill up, Islington's residents seemingly perfectly happy to board a bus they've never seen before. A keen toddler has coerced his parents to occupy the front seat. Someone sitting behind me thinks he's singing to himself.
Oh god are they still playing the "Hold onto the handrails while the bus is moving message"? It's been played THREE TIMES in the first ten minutes which is undoubtedly overkill (but thankfully only once more before we get to Battersea). At Angel we're joined by the 19 which has filtered in down Upper Street, and which we'll now shadow for the next 3 miles. Ahead is the section where the 19, 38 and new 10 all coincide, indeed on Rosebery Avenue they are the sole daytime routes listed on the bus stops. I'm impressed that there are now ten passengers on the upper deck given some Day 1s are mainly tumbleweed, also we've been making good time as we hurtle centralwards. However escaping Rosebery Avenue is our first bottleneck, the 12 second bursts of green light insufficient to let much traffic through.
At Holborn the 38 in front bears off and terminates by Red Lion Square. It seems incredible that this route, so long a workhorse, should have been so castrated it barely even reaches Bloomsbury, let along Piccadilly and Victoria. As recently as 2005 the 38 merited a bus every 2-3 minutes through central London, an iconic Routemaster cavalcade, yet here we are today with a peripheral service running every ten. Even last year the 38 was London's 14th busiest bus route but it'll never ever be top twenty again. On we plough towards New Oxford Street, the front seat toddler yelling "thankyou driver" as he alights. We've reached Tottenham Court Road in just under half an hour, which I reckon is pretty good given I expected this would be a crawl through snarled-up purgatory and it isn't, but that's Saturday mornings for you.
I see what used to be Foyles bookshop has become a gaudy beauty spa called Skin Cupid, also the All Bar One at Cambridge Circus has become a McDonalds, also a new Wetherspoons is just about to open in the old Trocadero. Shaftesbury Avenue turns out to be the slowest part of the entire route, alas one red light after another. It also has just three daytime buses with very low numbers, the 10, 14 and 19, and I wonder if there's anywhere else in London that can claim a lower trio. Downstairs an obvious tourist steps aboard to ask the driver "Are you going to Hyde Park Corner?", the bus stops here being timetableless, and stays aboard when the answer is yes. The shop windows down Piccadilly have already been Christmassified. Green Park would perhaps be better named Orangey-Brown Park at the moment. And blimey maybe six bus routes under 25 (9, 10, 14, 19, 22, 23) is a unique record too.
The bus is much emptier now as we edge away from very-central London. At Hyde Park Corner two Men Who Like Buses step out suicidally into the traffic so they can get a better photo of the new route for their collection. Hyde Park Corner is unique because it's the one stop on the journey where the previous 10 to Hammersmith coincides with the new 10 to Battersea - thankfully nobody appears to have waited eight years for our return. It's also where the 19 now bears off to Victoria, not many stops away, because the 10 has become the new 19 overnight and still has 2½ miles to go. Winter Wonderland has almost finished setting up in Hyde Park. Knightsbridge's lampposts have grown sparkly Christmas lanterns halfway down, which looks improperly anachronistic. They're already selling Christmas trees in the middle of Sloane Square and, amazingly, people have turned up to buy them.
Welcome to the King's Road, Chelsea's chi-chi-est street, where we are but one of five different bus routes heading onwards. This means the 319 ahead of us is hoovering up all the passengers and our driver merely follows behind, eventually managing to overtake. We speed down to Beaufort Street where 19s were often turned early if traffic was too clogged, and where 10s likely will too because it's a highly congestible route. And finally we nudge across Battersea Bridge, the Thames sparkling in the autumn chill, beyond which we are summarily dumped at the first stop so the 10 can turn into Battersea bus garage and the driver can enjoy a worthy break. I'm amazed that it took only 60 minutes to get here, I'd feared much longer, thus you may be relieved I managed to restrict my reportage to just ten minutes per paragraph.
0m Newington Green → 10m Angel → 20m Grays Inn Road → 30m Tottenham Court Road → 40m Green Park → 50m Sloane Square → 60m Battersea Bridge
So remember, if you're south of Angel the 10 is the new 19 and the 19 is the new 38. And whatever it says aboard the bus, the 10 doesn't go to Victoria.
Two weeks before Oxford Street was pedestrianised I rode buses up and down the selected stretch to see how long it took. Two weeks afterwards I've been back with my stopwatch to do the same. The question I wanted to answer was "how much longer does it take?"
What I did
• I went to Oxford Street late on a Friday morning.
• I rode the 94, 98, 139 and 390 once in both directions.
• I rode from the stop before the closure to the stop after.
• I timed the journey and counted how many times a red light stopped us.
Here are the times I got pre-pedestrianisation.
94
east
Marble Arch → Oxford Circus
1.1km
8m 10s
(5 red lights)
98
east
Marble Arch → Oxford Circus
1.3km
7m 40s
(5 red lights)
390
east
Marble Arch → Oxford Circus
1.3km
7m 00s
(5 red lights)
94
west
Oxford Circus → Marble Arch
1.1km
8m 10s
(8 red lights)
98
west
Oxford Circus → Marble Arch
1.2km
10m 10s
(8 red lights)
390
west
Oxford Circus → Marble Arch
1.4km
9m 50s
(8 red lights)
8 minutes, then, was a decent average for bussing along Oxford Street.
I didn't ride the 94 yesterday because it's been cut back to Marble Arch so longer reaches Oxford Circus. But I did go back and ride the 98 and 390 back and forth between exactly the same bus stops at Marble Arch and Oxford Circus, this time along the prescribed parallel diversion via Wigmore Street.
And yes, post-pedestrianisation it did indeed take longer.
98
east
Marble Arch → Oxford Circus
1.8km
11m 20s
(7 red lights)
390
east
Marble Arch → Oxford Circus
1.8km
14m 30s
(10 red lights)
98
west
Oxford Circus → Marble Arch
1.6km
14m 20s
(12 red lights)
390
west
Oxford Circus → Marble Arch
1.6km
13m 30s
(10 red lights)
13 minutes, now, is a decent average for bussing round Oxford Street. That's 5 minutes longer than before.
Previously all the journeys were 10 minutes or less, now they're all over 10 minutes. The main reason for this is that the route is longer, at least 500m longer, because buses have to head up to Wigmore Street and then head back. This increases the number of junctions which inevitably increases the number of red lights. For westbound buses Marylebone Lane has a particularly brief flash of green, so if you get stuck there you could be stuck for ages.
In my previous survey there were 5-8 stoppages at red, but this it was time more like 10. I thought my eastbound 98 was properly speeding through, getting lucky with the greens, but it still took longer than all the previous journeys.
One issue is a set of temporary traffic lights at the junction of Oxford Street and Great Portland Street where roadworks have narrowed the road. It's fairly narrow anyway, Great Portland Street not being especially suitable as a main thoroughfare, especially where it doubles up as a stand for route 73. We got through the lights fairly easily so they barely held us up, but in their absence journey times might (might) have been up to a minute shorter.
I've kept route 139 separate because it goes a different way and never reaches Marble Arch, hopping instead between Regent Street and Baker Street. This means it doesn't have to come back to Oxford Street so the diversion via Wigmore Street is the same length as the previous route. But does same length mean same time?
Here's before and after on the 139.
139
east
Portman Square → Hamleys
1.4km
8m 30s
(7 red lights)
139
west
Hamleys → Portman Square
1.3km
8m 20s
(7 red lights)
139
east
Portman Square → Hamleys
1.4km
10m 30s
(7 red lights)
139
west
Hamleys → Portman Square
1.3km
9m 20s
(6 red lights)
Average beforehand 8½ minutes, average afterwards 10 minutes. That's 1½ minutes longer than before.
A much smaller difference this time, but still slower because there's now more traffic on Wigmore Street than there was previously on Oxford Street. It's a very small sample of journeys so perhaps don't read too much into it, but it does looks like any impact to route to 139 is much smaller.
TfL produced an impact assessment as part of their consultation into pedestrianising Oxford Street and here's what their predictions said.
Bus journey time
• Most local bus routes would operate similar journey times, seeing an overall change of a minute or less in the AM and PM peaks.
• The routes that would experience the largest increase in journey time are the 98 and the 390. These routes previously used Oxford Street and are proposed to use a longer route via Wigmore St.
• Route 98 west would see journey times increase 2-3 minutes in the AM and 3-5 minutes in the PM peak.
• Route 98 east would see journey times increase 3-5 minutes in the AM and 2-3 minutes in the PM peak.
TfL predicted route 98 would take 2-5 minutes longer at peak times.
My survey showed routes 98 and 390 are taking 4-5 minutes longer off-peak.
TfL predicted route 139 would take ½-2 minutes longer at peak times.
My survey showed route 139 is taking 1½ minutes longer off-peak.
Viewed in percentage terms it looks worse. For these precise journeys route 139 is taking 15% longer and routes 98 and 390 are taking 60% longer. The increase on the 139 is dismissible but on the 98 and 390 it's significant.
On the day Oxford Street was pedestrianised TfL Commissioner Andy Lord went on BBC London and said this.
He was wrong.
It is true that the dozen buses that glance either end of the pedestrianised section won't have seen a significant difference in journey time. However the two routes that would have travelled along the pedestrianised section have been noticeably slowed, on a good day by 4-5 minutes and in heavy traffic likely a lot more.
Bus routes along Oxford Street between Selfridges and Oxford Circus
It looked lovely under the Christmas lights yesterday with a multitude of shoppers walking in the street where previously they'd have been mown down. But if you're visiting do try to avoid taking either of the two bus routes running parallel to Oxford Street, the 98 and 390, because they now take a lot longer and any festive spirit will soon be squeezed away.
You may remember the old Elephant & Castle shopping centre, an ugly 1960s warren filled with lowly businesses that served the community.
Pound stores when a pound actually bought you something, food from Poland and Latin America, inexpensive homewares, market stalls selling trinkets and stockings, tiny units selling hair fashions (aka wigs and straighteners), the formica tables of Jenny's Burgers, a daily 'Food Market', somewhere to get your photocopying done, DIY from Pricebusters, Stella's sequin emporium, £1.50 espressos, an Aladdin's cave of phonecases, authentic empanadas, halal tandoori, every kind of hat, and up the escalator Palace Bingo and Bowling, an affordable night out, a true melting pot, somewhere to shop and hang out, a retail village under striplights at the very heart of the Elephant.
I can't say there were no big chains because there was a Tesco Metro and a Co-op, also a Peacocks, the very barometer of affordable fashion, also a Clarks factory shop for those who merely wanted shoes rather than statements, but generally these were independent traders en masse in an increasingly unloved stacked mall providing employment for and service to everyday people.
The shopping centre closed in July 2020, long run down and already substantially emptied, in preparation for the wrecking ball and the arrival of cranes, a companion demolition to the neighbouring Heygate estate whose Brutalist walkways and smashed windows had already been replaced by the fresh flats of Elephant Park, a blatant gentrification landgrab by Southwark council, a different kind of soulless, its concierged shoeboxes surrounding artificial gardens laughably desribed as parkland.
Many decanted traders were relocated to a ribbed timber structure packed with micro retail units, potentially temporary but permitting the continuation of trade for beauty salons and Caribbean takeaways from the old place, at least until rent increases or failing footfall kicked them out, the writing already on the wall round the corner where new restaurants offered Italian, Japanese and 'small plates & grill', somewhere to graze and brunch, also maker spaces in Insta-friendly sheds, all with patronage from next-gens who wouldn't have dreamt of browsing hereabouts previously.
And now once again all change.
Yesterday the new Elephant & Castle shopping centre opened its doors, or rather cut its tape because this mall's outside, same place but no roof, a looping piazza surrounded by apartment towers.
They sent Percy Pig to open it, the anchor tenant being M&S Food, a queue round the block before ribbon-cutting at eight, in they poured, still pouring in at lunchtime, chicken wraps and poke bowls, hummus and pickybits, the interior supposedly "market-style" but just looks like shelves, and outside a giant inflatable Percy, its arms tied down with pink sandbags, quite the talking point, "thank god we can buy nice things here now".
Opposite is Mango for sophisticated outfits and accessories, ideally beige, then round the corner Søstrene Grene, a Danish homeware shop simply taking advantage, then opposite obviously Oliver Bonas, the very epitome of an unnecessary shop, all lifestyle goods and spur-of-the-moment giftables, you know your local population has cash potential when an Oliver Bonas turns up to siphon off their disposable income, another glass bowl for the cupboard, another influencer cookbook for the shelf, they wouldn't have spat on the previous shopping centre but here they are at the heart of the new, a defining presence.
As for standard chains Starbucks was a slamdunk, Pret A Manger was baked in, and Superdrug is the sole offer for those of more limited means, yes you can still get toothpaste and toilet rolls at The Elephant but the smellies might be selling better, and hang on is that it, the opening selection's pretty thin, the map of the mall has been padded out with half a dozen shops yet to open, these empty shells including Office for branded shoes, anything but Clarks, also a botoxmonger called Injectual, not health but wellness, "the first 50 to book receive a complimentary year of icon membership", also hot drink dispensers to cover all bases - one berry-based, one oriental chai - lest anyone pass through the development without a cup in their hand, heaven forfend.
There is an upstairs, its yellow escalator appearing tempting but if you risk the ascent it takes you to an upper level where as yet bugger all is trading, an exorbitant Everyman Cinema waiting to pounce, a food market taking shape behind glass doors, coming soon 14 Authentic Kitchens Serving Authentic Dishes, this the honeytrap to encourage sticky footfall, packed with long tables and laptop space, "where food becomes a shared story", "bringing people together through bold flavours and spaces that spark connection", basically a few bowls of brothy ramen and nibbling your friend's katsu, basically a social life for Gen Zs and millennials, that's opening later in the month and then this place truly takes off, if twice the price of anything offered by the previous tenants.
Hate this.
Whatever marketing team they've got sloganising the place needs locking up, merely reading the walls can bring on a fit of deep-seated bile, A Home For Gatherings & Good Vibes, Where Worlds Meet, Live In The Moment, Live More London, Be A Part Of London's New Chapter, Flavours Pop, Art Goes Bold, Drums Beat, Stories Unfold, this is what an English degree gets you these days, a job pumping out word salad on the walls of lifestyle developments, and not just the walls have you read the website, sheesh the website.
🐘 Easy to find. Hard to forget.
🐘 A canvas for experiential retail.
🐘 Contrasts, collisions, chance discoveries.
🐘 A melting pot of food, music and creative energy.
🐘 A convergence point for culture, commerce and community.
🐘 London’s newest destination for shopping, dining, work, wellness, entertainment and culture.
🐘 The Elephant’s more than a destination, it’s a neighbourhood.
🐘 Come worship at yet another identikit Temple of Brands.
🐘 Not that last one, I made that up.
Admittedly they've got footfall sewn up, a new tube entrance opening in 2028, a captive audience pouring past nothing it needs, also a new entrance to the Thameslink station, signed but not yet open, also a tower of students ready to dodge work by hanging out in the food hall, meanwhile the last of the traders from the old place eke out a living on the wrong side of the viaduct where business is about to be sucked dry by this new retail magnet, you can't argue with an M&S Food and fast fashion.
If you'd not seen the old place you might think this an excellent new hub and hangout, if you had seen the old place you might think it a vast improvement, I have seen the old place and I wonder where the old clientele went, have they really ceased to exist or have they simply been displaced, who thought them no longer worth supporting, why the re-pitch upmarket, there is zero overlap between the old Elephant and the new, gentrification switchover now effectively complete, a displacement of those without funds in favour of those with, from independent traders to the hottest brands, and would you like a bag of Percy Pigs with that?
You do not need to come to The Elephant, it's a generic skyscraperfoot mall, a high street without the useful bits, a day out for those with no imagination, but come they will, one half conveniently forgetting the other half exists.
LONDON A-Z W is for Upper Woodcote Village (the Webb Estate)
Just west of Purley is an extraordinary housing estate of extremely desirable houses in an extremely desirable setting. The Webb Estate was the brainchild of William Webb, a local estate agent with a grand vision and a pioneer of the garden village movement. If I tell you work started in 1888 and was completed in 1925, all to schedule, that'll tell you something about the singular determination of the man who built it. And if I tell you the estate covers 260 acres and has just 230 homes, that'll tell you something about the pockets of the people who live here.
The main entrance to Upper Woodcote Village, the road residents don't mind you using, bears off Smitham Bottom Lane by the old people's home. A minute's walk takes you to an unexpectedly rural vista - what looks like a pub, what looks like a village green - amid what otherwise is a neighbourhood of rustic commuter homes. Were it nicer weather you could stretch out on the sloping greensward, perhaps noting how few homes there are around the perimeter of so large a green. And if you entered the 'pub' you'd discover it doesn't sell beer, never has in 123 years, because The Lord Roberts on the Green started out as a Temperance Inn and still sells nothing stronger than a double espresso. What on earth is going on here?
William Webb's big idea was to perfect the landscaping before any houses got built. In 1888 he divided up his newly-purchased fields into several large plots and separated them all by privet hedges, rows of shrubs and semi-mature trees. He then waited another ten years before starting to sell off the plots, triggered finally by the arrival of trams into Purley. William didn't build the houses, he let purchasers choose their own architects and build what they wanted, each screened from its neighbour by a natural boundary as if part of "one large garden". The first house to be completed was his own, this in 1903, tucked away at the very heart of the residential swirl. So glacial was development that the majority took place between 1912 and 1920, and the final roof tile wasn't laid until 37 years after the project began. That's a "Gardens First" philosophy for you.
The Lord Roberts on the Green was one of the earliest openings and included a Post Office as well as a Tea Room, but no alcohol because Temperance and the Garden City movement were often bedfellows. Later owners diversified into general provisions, and this useful mix continued until 2017 when the Post office closed and the dining options nudged firmly upmarket. The current refreshment offer is coffee and chic cakes with a broad hot menu, very much targeted at those who wouldn't dream of lunch at Dobbies. Outside is the War Memorial, recently wreathed, on which are written the names of 345 dead soldiers from Coulsdon & Purley Urban District. It seems bold to locate the two towns' commemorative focus here, in neither town centre, but Webb was very pro-remembrance and you ain't seen nothing yet.
The green is sparse in facilities as well as neighbours. There are only three benches, two at the top end, also a single seesaw as a sop to younger residents seeking recreation. The village stocks are of course fake, there being nobody nearby in medieval times, and the artificial whipping post has already been removed. Close by are two roads into the remainder of the estate where the vast majority of residents live, each behind a gate drivers need a fob to open. Every entrance to the inner estate is gated, often in very different styles, and some have gatekeeper's cottages alongside from the days when everything had to be approved manually. Signs say PRIVATE ROAD Residents Only Please Drive Slowly No Through Road No Parking No Driving Tuition (or some combination of the above). Rest assured that if you're on foot you can simply push through the side gates and discover how the other half live.
The majority of the Village comprises nine interconnected avenues, each with its own horticultural focus. Rose Walk has a rose border in front of every plot, South Border has a herbaceous bed, Briar Hill has briar hedges and Woodcote Lane was intended to resemble a country lane. Silver Lane is named after the two rows of silver birches that stretch its full length, although their leaves are currently falling like rain and a more appropriate name would be Golden Walk. The roads are broad, quiet and lined by not many houses that can't necessarily be seen very clearly. Webb insisted that every house be at least 60 feet from a road and 10 feet from its side boundaries, also that all outbuildings should be suitably screened by shrubbery. Leases also demanded no subdivision into flats, no businesses to trade on the premises and absolutely no washing to be hung out to dry "unless hidden by a hedge or other suitable enclosure", rules which are still (mostly) followed.
The houses are unexpectedly diverse, except perhaps in size where they're generally enormous. Most are Metro-land on steroids, with broad frontages because the large plots gave architects a lot of width to play with. Some are entered via big swing gates, some have topiary swirls in the front garden and most are uber-chimneyed. Only one has statuesque gorillas guarding one of its gateposts, a pig at the other and lions outside the front door. A few are definitely modern additions, say on the site of former tennis courts, but because the estate's such a smorgasbord of styles it all fits together coherently. Webb's homes were initially affordable to City commuters but these days you need to be a lot wealthier. Former residents include Michael Bublé, Francis Rossi, Sir Bernard Ingham and Ron Noades (the boss of Crystal Palace), and current residents would rather not let you know they're here.
To walk the streets isn't too oppressive, other folk are out jogging, directing the builders or returning from the LROTG, also Purley's big Tesco is less than a mile away down Furze Hill. That said the gardener at Weathercote did give me quite a look as if to say "what on earth are you doing here?", even though I'd just walked to the end of his drive along an official public footpath. I was here to admire the strangest road of all, Promenade de Verdun, which was included as a living memorial to all the French soldiers who died during the First World War. It's the only straight road on the estate, runs for half a kilometre and leads to a shrubby dead end with a granite memorial obelisk. This is only inscribed in French - "Aux soldats de France morts glorieusement pendant la Grande Guerre" - a timely reminder that remembrance doesn't have to stop at home and should also look overseas.
The most striking feature of Promenade de Verdun is its row of Lombardy poplars. This runs the full length of the road, initially along a chained-off strip signed Keep Off Verge. The reason for this caution is that the soil beneath the poplars was transported wholesale from the "Field of Explosion" near Armentieres, all ten tons of it, with all the shrapnel sifted out lest souvenir hunters damage the trees through their digging. It's an extraordinary statement of Anglo-French support conceived at a time when postwar relations were strained, and I'd say more affecting than the war memorial on the village green. The Promenade is just one of the reasons Webb was keen the wider public should enjoy his estate, the intrinsic landscaping being the main draw, so feel free to come and walk a circuit. It's barely any distance from Purley town centre, also you can always stop off for a pistachio latte halfway round, and I've already pencilled in a return when the Rose Walk is at its finest.
It's about time I visited an unsung suburb in Sutton, London's most unsung borough. And this one's really off-radar, despite having several distinct parts and covering up to two square miles. You'll find Woodcote south of Wallington, west of Purley and north of Coulsdon amid a rural fringe most Londoners can't even comprehend. The main nucleus is Woodcote Green but there's also Upper Woodcote (which the Ordnance Survey annotates as Woodcote), the outlier of Little Woodcote and a heck of a lot of roads called Woodcote Something, also no pubs and hardly any pre-20th century buildings. Let's see what I can find.
Woodcote Green does indeed have a green and it's triangular in shape (very much scalene, largest angle about 110). The shortest side is part of the main road between Carshalton and Coulsdon, thus quite busy, while the hypotenuse is lined by well-spaced detached houses. An awful lot of Woodcote is occupied by "well-spaced detached houses", and at the very least its residents get a broad semi with a decent-sized garden. The green has everything you'd expect - moulting trees, dog mess bins and the remains of a seven-stick Sky Master rocket propped up in a litter bin, no doubt left over from a guerilla display at the weekend. Unusually it also has a WW2 air raid shelter in one corner, its bricked up entrance still intact and with a very obvious flattened hump evident in the grass beyond.
The green also has a very informative information board, which is just as well because Wikipedia's page on Woodcote Green is only two sentences long and otherwise the history of this place would be a mystery. There was a village here in 1332, the steamed-up text says, which at the time was larger than Wallington. But by 1586 the village had vanished and no traces remain, with what's now the green just a triangular field. Even the arrival of a railway at Wallington a mile to the north failed to spur development, other than a brief terrace of Edwardian council houses by the green, until in the 1920s rustic avenues swallowed up acres of farmland and merged into the adjacent towns. It probably doesn't help with local identity that Sutton council have erected a huge sign at the tip of the green but instead of Welcome to Woodcote Green it says Welcome to Wallington.
The dominant buildings here belong to Wallington High School for Girls which moved here in 1965 and which is now 20-times oversubscribed, so they must be doing something excellent. Come while they're in lessons and it's extremely quiet but time things for late afternoon and I imagine a throng of dark green blazers heads across the road to Woodcote Green's sole corner shop. A sign demands no more than three pupils enter at a time, but also demands they "strictly keep a distance from each other" because its been sellotaped to the door since lockdown. Other local sights include half a quaint cottage that appears to be in rapid decay, a shifted horse trough and an MOT-friendly garage that acted as an auxiliary fire station during WW2. I feel I'm scraping the barrel somewhat here.
↖ To find the oldest building hereabouts head north towards Wallington and turn off down Woodcote Avenue. The well-spaced detached houses eventually reach a maroon sign proclaiming that the remainder of the loop is a private road, and absolutely definitely no learner drivers. On the back it additionally warns that "the Woodcote Avenue Road Fund accept no responsibility for damage or injury caused by this sign" which is a level of litigative paranoia I'm not used to seeing writ large. The first building is Woodcote Hall, formerly one of the country seats of the Carews of Beddington, for many centuries the local landowning nobility. The latest incarnation alas isn't medieval, it's two Georgian stucco properties joined in the centre by a later extension and since converted to 14 flats, so nothing to walk out of your way for.
↘ Another post-Carew nucleus was Great Woodcote Farm, this to the southeast off Foxley Lane. I can tell you that in 1859 it comprised 622 acres, that its Edwardian owner helped found Purley Cricket Club, that in 1931 a ‘cat burglar’ made off with a £1000 haul of jewellery and furs. During WW2 it was also the HQ of Field Consolidated Aircraft Services Ltd, being highly convenient for Croydon Airport. However the farmhouse then became uninhabitable while its land was turned over to housing, and if you turn up at the corner of Farm Road and The Ridge today all you'll find are well-spaced detached houses and broad semis with a decent-sized garden. Half-timbered gables are extremely popular, also topiary services probably pay well, and if anything the apartment block on the farmhouse's footprint is the least impressive building of all.
↙ Little Woodcote is a completely different matter, still mostly undeveloped in favour of lowly agricultural usage. Surrey County Council created smallholdings here after the Great War to create employment for returning soldiers, buying up land previously used for the growing of lavender and peppermint. Construction began in 1920, and 79 cottages were built (total cost £87,875), each with a few acres of land. Somewhat unexpectedly these weatherboarded semi-detached beauties are still here, if mostly no longer used for their original purpose, and to walk its crisscross of tracks is to step back into a twitchy backwater of microbusinesses and scrappy paddocks. I wrote about Little Woodcote in 2017 so didn't re-explore fully this time, but if you were ever to visit stick it in your top three sights to see.
← What I did do is walk down Woodmansterne Lane to the first of the nurseries, Woodcote Green being the south London equivalent of Crews Hill. It's a Dobbies and once you've finally crossed the car park it turns out to be vast, also very much not just a garden centre. I wandered in past shelves of yarn and jigsaws, also a rack of sparkly personalised tote bags, also knitted welly socks and a special offer 20% reduction on branded wellingtons. The food hall stocked giftable chutneys and a display of Diddly Squat wines, beyond which an illuminated village was helping to flog collectible Bavarian miniatures. It felt more like I was up in Norfolk than on the edge of zone 5. But what really took my breath away were the restaurant and cafe which were both mostly full, despite it only being elevenses and still too early for a Cumberland Sausage Ring. This it turns out is the beating heart of Woodcote Green, its community centre and economic heart combined, because who needs any other village facilities when you've got a Dobbies?
↲ I had one more old building to try to visit and that was Woodcote Grove, an unswallowed country house once the abode of the Campbell-Johnstons. To get there I followed the entirety of Woodcote Park Avenue, lined initially by some of the most exceptional well-spaced detached houses, even by Woodcote standards. On the first bend the tarmac runs out and the road becomes an unmade track entering a tunnel of yellowing leaves, running alongside a field in which Dogs Must Not Be Exercised. Four other exclusive avenues join at intervals, as desirably peripheral as London gets without tipping over into gated hell. Over the hedge is a patch of privatised allotments, a company called Roots taking advantage of Sutton's four year waiting list, complete with central teepee. Finally at the end of what feels like a country lane is yet another big secondary school, that's Woodcote High, also a recreation ground so unloved the welcome sign's disappeared. And turn right.
↲ At the top of Meadow Hill is Woodcote Park Golf Club, founded in 1912 and with a splendid monogram above what used to be the clubhouse door. The course has eight flat holes to the south, ten sloping holes to the north and an obliging membership who enjoy a civilised circuit before retiring to the Captain's Lounge. A farm track leads past a row of tractors to the entrance of Orford House care home, which it turns out is what Woodcote Grove was ultimately repurposed as, and far enough up the drive to be entirely inaccessible. It's just one of Woodcote's scattering of peripheral oddities, easily overlooked amid a blanket of well-spaced detached houses, indeed easily overlooked altogether. And I haven't even mentioned the most extraordinary Woodcote of all which is Upper Woodcote, a reclusive beauty that needs an entire post of its own...