diamond geezer

 Thursday, November 12, 2020

Anorak Corner [bus edition] (annual update)

Having only just brought you a tube update it's time to hit the roads. Yesterday TfL published their annual spreadsheet listing the number of passengers using every London bus route and how many kilometres those buses travelled. Data is for April 2019 - March 2020. Comparisons are with the previous year.

It's been quite a year. Four routes were withdrawn (10, C2, 48, RV1) and as many as seven new ones introduced. Hammersmith Bridge closed at the start of the reporting period disrupting several routes. And most recently the pandemic has ravaged passenger numbers, so much so that the new spreadsheet includes an extra column excluding the last four weeks of March. I'm using the full 12 months of data unless otherwise indicated.


London's ten busiest bus routes (2019/20)
  1) -- 18 Euston - Sudbury (15.7m)
  2)
↑3 149 London Bridge - Edmonton Green (13.2m)
  3)
-- 29 Trafalgar Square - Wood Green (12.7m)
  4)
↑3 207 White City - Southall (11.7m)
  5)
↑1 243 Waterloo - Wood Green (11.53m)
  6)
↓4 25 Holborn Circus - Ilford (11.52m)
  7)
↓3 140 Harrow Weald - Heathrow (11.50m)
  8)
-- 86 Stratford - Romford (11.4m)
  9) ↑1 38 Victoria - Clapton Pond (11.1m)
10)
↓1 36 Queens Park - New Cross Gate (11.0m)

The next ten: 5, 109, 279, 43, 141, 35, 185, 53, 254, 65

The 18 remains London's busiest bus route by a comfortable margin, with route 149 leapfrogging into second place. The Top 5 are all key services along busy radial corridors, either north towards Hackney and Haringey or west towards Ealing and Brent. Former topdog 25 continues to tumble after the western end of its route was removed and its frequency cut. The parallel 86 is now very close behind. The 140's fall follows the introduction of an express X140 route last December. Thirteen bus routes managed to convey more than ten million passengers (down from sixteen last year).

London's ten least busy bus routes (2019/20)
  1) -- 399 Barnet - Hadley Wood (10,632)
  2)
-- 389 Barnet - Underhill (15,393)
  3)
** 15H Trafalgar Square - Tower Hill (20,960)
  4)
↓1 H3 Golders Green - Hilltop (24,647)
  5)
↓1 R10 Orpington - Orpington ↺ (25,416)
  6)
↓1 W10 Enfield - Crews Hill (26,666)
  7)
↓1 R5 Orpington - Orpington ↻ (29,923)
  8)
↓1 385 Chingford - Crooked Billet (36,941)
  9)
↓1 347 Romford - Ockendon (39,524)
10)
** 497 Harold Wood - Harold Hill (57,000)

The next ten: 549, 375, 327, R8, 404, 146, U10, RV1, 467, 464

Most of these are the usual suspects, topped off by a pair of brief turns in Barnet connecting daytime residents to the shops. Peripheral infrequent buses don't attract much custom. But two newcomers have disrupted the rankings, and in very different parts of town...

The 15H Routemaster service had all its weekday and winter journeys scrapped last year, partly to protect its ageing vehicles. This has led to a massive 82% drop in passengers, not unsurprisingly, placing the heritage service firmly in the bottom three.

Meanwhile the 497 is a new route which runs not very far not very often in outer Havering. Officially it only carried 9218 passengers last year, so officially it's now London's least used bus. But the 497 was only introduced in January so accumulated just ten weeks of passengers before the end of March cut-off point, four of which were pandemic-affected. I've therefore decided it would be much fairer to calculate an expected annual total based on the six normal weeks, and this suggests the 497 should rightly be in 10th place instead. The 399's position as London's Least Used Bus remains secure.

London's ten most travelled bus routes (2019/20)
  1) ↑2 38 Victoria - Clapton (2,255,000km)
  2)
↑2 18 Euston - Sudbury (2,073,000km)
  3)
↓2 140 Harrow Weald - Heathrow (1,997,000km)
  4)
↑2 111 Kingston - Heathrow (1,917,000km)
  5)
↑5 86 Stratford - Romford (1,837,000km)
  6)
↑1 113 Oxford Circus - Edgware (1,836,000km)
  7)
↑2 5 Canning Town - Romford (1,821,000km)
  8)
-- 36 Queens Park - New Cross Gate (1,785,000km)
  9)
↑2 182 Harrow Weald - Brent Cross (1,753,000km)
10)
↑2 96 Woolwich - Bluewater (1,728,000km)

The next ten: 207, 472, 53, 102, 34, 65, 149, 13, 64, 427

This is a chart of the routes whose vehicles travelled the greatest distance in one year. High frequency buses (like the 38 and 18) and long distance buses (like the 113 and 96) tend to travel the furthest. These are the stalwarts of the London bus network. But several routes have risen two places in the chart this year because two former heavy hitters have fallen away. One is the 53, whose mileage is down 15% following curtailment and a frequency cut, and the other is the once mighty 25. Two years ago the 25 was top of the heap, shuttling back and forth 3 million kilometres annually, but in the latest figures that's halved to 1½ million and the route's not even in the Top 20. Meanwhile the 389 remains London's least travelled bus route, covering just under 8000 km per year.

London's ten most crowded bus routes (2019/20)
  1) -- W7 Finsbury Park - Muswell Hill (10 passengers per km)
  2)
-- 330 Canning Town - Forest Gate (9)
  3)
↑1 104 Stratford - Manor Park (8.8)
  4)
↑5 238 Stratford - Barking (8.8)
  5)
↓2 41 Archway - Tottenham Hale (8.7)
  6)
↑1 29 Trafalgar Square - Wood Green (8.5)
  7)
↓1 69 Canning Town - Walthamstow (8.4)
  8)
↓3 58 East Ham - Walthamstow (8.1)
  9)
↓1 109 Brixton - Croydon (8.1)
10)
** 35 Shoreditch - Clapham Junction (8.0)

This Top 10 is determined by dividing the number of passengers by the number of km travelled to get a 'number of passengers per km'. The higher the number, the less likely it is you'll be able to find a seat. By this measure the most crowded bus is still the W7 which, along with the 41, delivers residents of Muswell Hill and Crouch End to their nearest tube stations. Note the extremely strong presence of the London borough of Newham in this top 10, where buses are still the favoured way of getting around. The 35's new entry is at the expense of the 507 'Red Arrow' commuter route which no longer packs them in. Most London bus routes carry 2-5 passengers per km.

London's ten emptiest buses: R10, R5, 399, H3, R8, 146, 347, R7, 549, R2

Most of these buses run round the lanes of rural Bromley and Orpington. The wilds of Hadley Wood, Hampstead, North Ockendon and Roding Valley also get a look in. If you ever fancy an atypical London bus journey with every chance of a seat, this list ticks all the boxes.

The ten bus routes with the greatest annual increase in passengers: 425, 419, 265, 88, 125, 26, 35, 303, 289, 175
The ten bus routes with the greatest annual decrease in passengers: 15H, 209, 72, 45, 67, 25, 12, 485, 27, 388

Don't read too much into these two lists, as most of the big increases and decreases in passenger numbers since last year are the result of TfL changing the route. A number of these relate to the closure of Hammersmith Bridge, which has delivered a boost to the 419 and 265 but a hammerblow to the 209, 72, and 485. Route 67 was cut back from Aldgate to Dalston so its numbers went down 35%. Route 125 was extended from Finchley to Colindale so its numbers went up 21%. The really big winner is the 425 which has the greatest passenger increase of any London bus route for the second year running.... because that's where 3 million of route 25's passengers went.

London's most successful new bus routes (2019/20)
  1) X140 Harrow - Heathrow (4,000,000)
  2)
218 North Acton - Hammersmith (2,450,000)
  3)
306 Acton Vale - Sands End (2,400,000)
  4)
278 Ruislip - Heathrow (2,100,000)
  5)
301 Woolwich - Bexleyheath (1,500,000)
  6)
335 Kidbrooke - North Greenwich (1,200,000)
  7)
497 Harold Wood - Harold Hill (57,000)

I mentioned that seven new bus routes started during the survey period. Here's how well they're doing. To put things on an equal footing, given their different start dates, I've calculated average weekly ridership and multiplied this by 52. The clear winner is the express X140 which has nabbed passengers from the shortened 140. The 218 and 306 have very similar totals which is appropriate because they're very similar (overlapping) routes. The 278 has made a strong start in west London; the 301 and 335 less so in the southeast. And you can see just how far adrift the piddly 497 is, very much TfL as public service provider rather than commercial operator.

London's ten busiest nightbuses: N15, N29, N25, N18, N207, N9, N279, N8, N98, N38
London's ten least busy nightbuses: H37, E1, H32, 307, 132, 154, W3, W7, 296, 486

Barely a ripple here since last year's figures.

But next year's figures OMG, next year's will be nuts. They'll begin one week into lockdown when hardly anyone was travelling. They'll include a couple of months when passengers didn't have to pay to board so TfL won't have any data. Some routes returned to normal sooner than others which'll totally distort the rankings. And ridership is still way down, having only just crept up to maybe two-thirds of previous levels, so next year's totals will be incomparable. Make the most of Anorak Corner 2019/20, because it's the last that'll look even vaguely normal for some years to come.

 Wednesday, November 11, 2020

All that talk of tall buildings got me wondering how many there are in Greater London. This is a vexed question, because what counts as 'tall', what counts as finished, indeed what even counts as a building?

I decided tall meant 'over 100m' because that's Wikipedia's cut-off, whereas the City tends to say 75m. I included topped-out buildings that are already part of the skyline, even if not entirely complete. I discounted TV transmitters, telecoms towers, football stadia, observation decks and ferris wheels because they're structures rather than buildings.

I turned to Wikipedia's List of tallest buildings and structures in London, which has a gold star so I hoped would be accurate, and started bashing the data. Then I spotted it contained errors, for example a 2020 completion date on a massive residential tower that's still a hole in the ground, so went off and did a lot more research elsewhere. I ended up with almost 100 100m+ buildings on my list. I'm fairly happy with the results, but they won't be 'correct'.




Boroughs with the most tall buildings (100m+)
  1) Tower Hamlets (30)
  2)
City of London (21)
  3)
Southwark (9)
  4)
Newham (7)
  5)
Hackney (6)
  6)
Lambeth (4)
  7)
Camden (3)
  7)
Islington (3)
  7)
Wandsworth (3)
  7)
Westminster (3)
11)
Croydon (2)
11)
Hammersmith & Fulham (2)

» Tower Hamlets wins easily, entirely thanks to Docklands. The majority of skyscrapers are at Canary Wharf but significant clusters exist alongside at Blackwall and around Millwall Inner Dock. Highrise development kicked off with One Canada Square in 1991, then really powered ahead from 2002 onwards. All the early tall buildings were office blocks but the latest fashion is very much residential, indeed a comfortable majority of Tower Hamlets' 30 are for living rather than working. Being Britain's fastest growing borough, expect a lot more.
» The City's next, as we saw yesterday.

Between them the City and Tower Hamlets contain well over half of London's tall buildings.

» Southwark's 9 include the Shard, the UK's pre-eminent building, plus four other residential buildings on the South Bank and four more at Elephant & Castle.
» Newham's 7 are all in Stratford. Manhattan Loft Gardens (143m) is Outer London's tallest building.
» Hackney's 6 are almost all on the border with the City of London, but with a residential outlier at Woodberry Down.
» Lambeth = Vauxhall + the Shell Centre.
» Camden includes 1960s classics Centre Point and Euston Tower, plus a block of student accommodation behind King's Cross.
» Islington's whoppers lie along the City Road.
» Wandsworth's appearance is thanks to the explosion of development at Nine Elms, which is very much work in progress so expect numbers to shoot up imminently.
» Westminster's 3 are all more than fifty years old (Millbank Tower, Portland House, London Hilton). The council simply don't believe in highrise building, so the West End skyline remains in characterful contrast to the adjacent City.
» Croydon may be South London's Manhattan with twelve buildings over 60m, but only two are over 100m.
» Hammersmith & Fulham's 2 are the (1960s) Empress State Building and a new tower in White City.

The only other boroughs with a 100m+ building are Kensington & Chelsea, Haringey, Redbridge and (North) Greenwich.

The majority of London boroughs have no 100m+ buildings at all. They still have tall buildings, because in the suburbs height is entirely relative. But the really tall stuff restricts itself to where real estate is the most expensive, around London's two financial hubs.

Also, most of London's tall buildings are very recent. Over half are from the last decade, and most of these have been completed since 2015. By contrast only two 100m+ buildings were built between 1981 and 2000, both at Canary Wharf. The rush to build high is now relentless, or will be so long as London's economy holds out, changing the capital's skyline forever.

London's tallest buildings
  1) The Shard (310m)
  2)
22 Bishopsgate (278m)
  3)
One Canada Square (235m)
  4)
Landmark Pinnacle (233m)
  5)
Heron Tower (230m)
  6)
'Cheesegrater' (225m)
  7)
Newfoundland (220m)
  8)
South Quay Plaza 1 (215m)
  9)
One Park Drive (205m)
10)
8/25 Canada Square (200m)
 
     Tallest building by borough
  1) Southwark (310m)
  2)
City of London (278m)
  3)
Tower Hamlets (235m)
  4)
Lambeth (181m)
  5)
Hackney (161m)
  6)
Islington (155m)
  7)
Newham (143m)
  8)
Hammersmith & Fulham (139m)
  9)
Croydon (135m)
10)
Wandsworth (128m)
UK cities with tall buildings
  1) London (310m)
  2)
Manchester (201m)
  3)
Liverpool (140m)
  4)
Birmingham (130m)
  5)
Glasgow (127m)
  6)
Leeds (110m)
  7)
Swansea (107m)
  8)
Portsmouth (101m)
  8)
Sheffield (101m)
10)
Belfast (88m)
     Countries with tall buildings
  1) United Arab Emirates (828m)
  2)
China (632m)
  3)
Saudi Arabia (601m)
  4)
South Korea (555m)
  5)
United States (546m)
  6)
Taiwan (509m)
  7)
Malaysia (500m)
  8)
Hong Kong (484m)
  9)
Russia (380m)
10)
Thailand (367m)

 Tuesday, November 10, 2020

Why is there a cluster of tall buildings in the City of London?



It's partly because the City of London isn't averse to highrise development, but mainly because tall buildings are allowed to be built in some locations and not others.

For a full explanation you should read the 32 page planning document Tall Buildings in the City of London published in March 2019. I have, and I shall now oversimplify its contents for those of you with limited time. In short it's all about St Paul's Cathedral, but also to a lesser extent the Monument and the Tower of London.

For centuries the only tall buildings in the City were churches. In the 1930s the construction of a (gasp) 11 storey building caused consternation when it blocked views of St Paul's Cathedral from the Thames riverside. In response the City Corporation introduced a local view protection policy called the St Paul's Heights. This successfully kept highrise development at bay until the 1960s.



The St Paul's Heights plan was intended to protect local views of the cathedral from the South Bank, the Thames bridges (including Waterloo Bridge and London Bridge) and along certain key streets (such as Fleet Street). My map shows the affected area in orange. Views from the South Bank and bridges explain most of the large chunk nearest to the river, while three streets in Islington (Farringdon Road, Amwell Street and St John Street) account for the sector to the north. Maximum heights were calculated for individual grid squares across the entire zone (for example in the Smithfield area no building can exceed 52m). The St Paul's Heights plan remains in force.



In 1991 the government defined eight Strategic Views to protect sight of the dome of St Paul's Cathedral from more distant viewpoints. The eight chosen locations were:
» Greenwich Park and Blackheath Point in southeast London
» Primrose Hill, Parliament Hill, Kenwood and Alexandra Palace to the north
» Richmond Park and Westminster Pier to the southwest

The reason you can only see five sectors on the map, not eight, is that some of the corridors have merged before they reach the boundaries of the City.

Strategic Views were later devolved to the Mayor of London. In 2007 Ken Livingstone narrowed their width and renamed them Protected Vistas. In 2010 Boris Johnson widened them again as a compromise between the two previous widths. The London View Management Framework remains in force.



The Monument Views Policy Area protects and enhances views of and from the Monument. It includes the four street blocks surrounding the Monument, plus five protected views from the viewing gallery itself (towards the Tower, the Thames, London Bridge, Waterloo Bridge and St Paul's). It's shown above in green.

Meanwhile in yellow is an area to protect the silhouette of the Tower of London, specifically the White Tower, as seen from the opposite side of the Thames. World Heritage Site skylines must be preserved.

Lines of sight prohibit the construction of tall buildings in all of these areas - orange, red, green and yellow. But there's one more factor to take into account...



This is a map of the City's 27 Conservation Areas. The first was designated in 1971 and the most recent (the Golden Lane Estate and Barbican Estate) in 2018. Official policy is that the development of a tall building in a Conservation Area would be inappropriate, so no new ones are permitted. Light-coloured areas on the map show that the City isn't as chock-full with historic buildings as some might think - a lot is covered by generic demolishable office blocks.

Finally we can combine all of these maps together, as the City does, to create a map showing Areas inappropriate for tall buildings.



As you can see, most of the Square Mile has been blotted out leaving only a few areas suitable for highrise development. One is west of St Paul's around Fetter Lane. A larger patch spreads from London Wall down to Cheapside. A significant chunk is up north around Liverpool Street station. But the largest area of land available for tall buildings is to the east of Bishopsgate around Fenchurch Street and Leadenhall. This is where most of the whoppers have ended up, forming the so-called Eastern Cluster.

This final map shows the actual location of City buildings over 75m in height.



Light blue buildings precede 1970 - they're mostly churches. Red and yellow cover the rest of the 20th century, including the Barbican and Nat West Tower. Green brings us into the 2000s, including the Gherkin and the Broadgate Tower. Dark blue covers the last decade, confirming that construction has been speeding up recently. Empty circles show tall buildings under construction or not yet begun.

At present more than 60 City buildings exceed 75m in height and nine exceed 150m. Several more are on the drawing board. Most of the new batch are located inside an approximate triangle bounded by Liverpool Street station, Fenchurch Street station and Leadenhall Market. None are targeted for the western half of the City, nor anywhere near the river.

I've skated over all this, so if you're really interested you should read the full report. You may not like how high the City of London is climbing, nor how fast, but you can at least take comfort that tall buildings can't be built just anywhere... and we have St Paul's Cathedral to thank for that.

 Monday, November 09, 2020

Random City of London ward (3): Aldgate



My third random ward is adjacent to the second, one gate clockwise around the former London Wall. Aldgate, which probably means 'Old Gate', gives its name to an irregularly-shaped area best known for a vegetable-shaped skyscraper. More somewhere to pass through than a busy destination, there is nonetheless plenty to track down. [pdf map]



Aldgate has one of the strangest City ward boundaries, incorporating a thin tongue of land which follows the street of the same name without including any of the buildings to either side. Aldgate tube station perversely lies outside Aldgate ward, newly pedestrianised Aldgate Square has a broad stripe of not-Aldgate across its centre, and all so that the site of the original Aldgate can be technically attached to the ward. The twin-arched gateway was rebuilt several times during the medieval period, then entirely reconstructed in 1609, then removed in 1761 after becoming a serious hindrance to traffic. The approximate location is marked by the pedestrian crossing on the stopped-up gyratory just outside Boots.



Close by, at the fork in the road between Leadenhall Street and Fenchurch Street, is the ill-famed Aldgate Pump. Originally a medieval well fed by spring water it was capped by a Portland stone obelisk in the 18th century, then shifted slightly to be on the pavement rather than in the middle of the road. Its waters were praised for being "bright, sparkling and cool, and of an agreeable taste", until it became clear that the mineral tang came from the leaching of calcium from the bones of the buried dead. The New River Company promptly changed the supply to mains water. Last year the Heritage of London Trust restored the pump, scrubbed the wolf's head spout and replaced the lantern on the top so it's all looking particularly splendid, but if you fancy a drink the Co-Op alongside is a much safer bet.



Three things to spot near Aldgate Pump
• Hartshorn Alley: A perplexingly modern alleyway burrowed behind the Co-Op to give access to several fire exits and a bookmakers, and just wiggly enough to be highly disconcerting.
• London Metal Exchange: The LME moved somewhere cheaper in 2016 so their former trading floor has been appropriated for the War of the Worlds Immersive Experience. The owners hope you'll top-up their £72.50 ticket price with a halfway cocktail and a meal in a steampunk restaurant, but the protracted alien assault has recently been immobilised by a tiny virus (which is wonderfully appropriate).
• Mitre Square: The site of Jack the Ripper's only City murder, and recently remodelled to remove all trace of the last authentic cobbles.



The ward's most famous building is the Gherkin, or 30 St Mary Axe to use its proper name. Completed in 2003, its dildoesque silhouette is both instantly recognisable and much loved, although an increasing cluster of surrounding towers makes it a lot harder to spot these days. Its tenants are mostly insurance companies, although there is currently space to rent on the 32nd and half the 27th floors if you're interested. The spell breaks slightly if you stand underneath, the rising latticed skeleton somewhat overwhelmed by a drab piazza watched over by swivelling cameras.



Five things to spot around the Gherkin
• The Baltic Exchange: The original building at 24-28 St Mary Axe, home to a membership of 650 shipping companies worldwide, was mostly destroyed by an IRA blast in 1992. The Gherkin now occupies the site, and the Baltic Exchange has moved nextdoor to a less-wow building at number 38.
• Grave of a Roman girl: While excavating the Gherkin site contractors uncovered the skeleton of a girl, later determined to be about 15 years of age, buried circa 400 AD. She was reinterred at the same spot in 2007. The site is now marked with a laurel wreath and a Latin inscription.
• Holland House: Facing the Gherkin on Bury Street is the striking facade of an elegant office block built in 1916 for a Dutch shipping company. The southeast corner is marked by a splendid granite sculpture of the prow of a ship.
• Site of the Fall – study of the renaissance garden: Action 180: At 9:15 am Sunday 28 May 1967: That's a very long title for one of this year's exhibits from Sculpture In The City, a striking marble figure of a victim of the Vietnam War with a bag over his head.
• The Same for Everyone: More art from the same collection, this time an illuminated phrase appropriated by Nathan Coley and dropped into Cunard Place.



One thing not to spot around the Gherkin
• The Tulip: 20 Bury Street is an insignificant six-storey office block in one corner of the Gherkin's piazza, and the proposed site of Foster & Partners' latest assault on the City's skyline. They want to build a 305m-high visitor attraction resembling an erect sperm, constrained only by a minimal footprint at ground level. Supporters claim it'll bring cultural and economic benefits including viewing galleries, restaurants and (eek!) a loop of glass gondola pods circling the exterior of the building. Lest that sound too frivolous the plans also include a 'classroom in the sky', but the real aim is to outShard the Shard as a must-visit global experience. The Mayor said no, it'd be appallingly intrusive, but a higher level planning appeal is underway this week and who knows, aerial desecration may be back on.



Aldgate ward lies at a sweet spot within the City for highrise development, a convenience numerous developers have duly taken advantage of. As well as the Gherkin we now have the Scalpel, a 38-storey angular tower with a slanting triangular face on top (but only visible from South London). Alongside is the 26-storey triple-stepped Willis Building, which architects thought tall in 2008, while over on Houndsditch is the impressively smooth Can of Ham. Demolition work is almost complete at 40 Leadenhall Street where a dense glass monster awaits erection. To walk around Aldgate is to peer into vast ground floor atriums where reception staff sit alone across unnecessarily wide foyers and lines of security gates lead to banks of escalators ascending to where the real work gets done.



Three places of worship to spot around Aldgate
• Bevis Marks Synagogue: Britain's oldest synagogue in continuous use dates back to 1701 when most of the City's Jewish population lived in and around Aldgate. Set in a secluded courtyard off Bevis Marks, and still a safe refuge, visitors are normally welcomed for a fiver (National Trust members half price). It's quite the experience.
• St Andrew Undershaft: Rare survivor of both the Great Fire and the Blitz, soon approaching its quincentenary, better known as "that old church you can get a photo of with the Gherkin rising behind".
• St Katharine Cree: London's only Jacobean church, more impressive within than without. Being a City church it closes over the Christmas period, which is ecumenically perverse.



Aldgate ward used to extend well south of Fenchurch Street, but millennial restructuring lopped off all but a stubby tongue either side of Lloyd's Avenue. Here we find Lloyd's Register (not Lloyd's of London, but from the same coffeehouse roots), founded in 1760 to serve the needs of merchant shipping. Their Renaissance-style HQ was used by Monty Python in swashbuckling skit The Crimson Permanent Assurance, and augmented a century later by a towering Richard Rogers steel and glass extension bolted onto the side. As ever Open House is your key to getting inside, but for now treading the surrounding streets will have to do.

 Sunday, November 08, 2020

The best recent science fiction, fantasy, crime and horror – book review roundup

Sarah Baker's debut novel, Red Wall (Penguin, £12.99), presents a plausible post-pandemic society following the enforced division of England by a ten metre electric fence. Chris lives north of the wall in the ruins of X-Manchester, hollowed out by poverty and disease, but seeks reconciliation with childhood sweetheart Beth from virus-free Cambridg£. One of them must find a way across the barrier which divides them, deftly dodging the Border Force robots who shoot presumed migrants on sight, without triggering the microchipped BloodKlot implant which keeps wayward youth in check. Baker movingly charts Beth's coming of age story as her world and Chris's collide.

When a defeated President refuses to leave the White House quietly, a dangerous stand-off ensues. Robert Drakeman's latest thriller, Bunker Down (Faber, £14.99), imagines an entirely hypothetical situation in which a trigger-happy narcissist refuses to attend his successor's inauguration and takes refuge on a golf course with the nuclear codes. As FBI agents surround the clubhouse, social media bosses must decide whether or not to delete the President's account before Air Force One drops its deadly payload. Although Drakeman ramps up the tension from the tee-off, the denouement is sadly below par.

In Rollback (Titan, £8.99), Kendra McKay presents a frighteningly real near-future in which global health systems have been overwhelmed by a super-infectious virus. A team of scientists builds a time machine to send a vaccine taskforce back to 2018 in an attempt to warn society and prevent the outbreak from occurring. But in a very obvious twist which even a schoolchild could have seen coming, they unintentionally take the virus back with them and set off the whole crisis off several months early, so that when they return to the future they discover things are ten times worse. A subplot involving a cat giving birth to itself fails to lighten the mood.

Billed as a political pseudo-thriller, Party Games (Gollancz, £18.99) is the latest novella by Orion-winner Bernard Castle. After the Queen abruptly dies from Covid-19, her infection is traced back to a superspreader party celebrating Wilfred Johnson's 1st birthday at 10 Downing Street. As the country enters an unprecedented period of riotous mourning, DC Lena Nblisi must tackle an official veil of silence to uncover the wilful incompetence at the heart of power. An incisive tale of subverted justice, party favours, post-truth and plausible deniability.

A high-concept saga as much as a dystopian page-turner, Seb Danzig's Tuktuk (HarperCollins, £16.99) is the tale of Amir Kumar, a downtrodden Peckham resident eking out a hard life as a scooter-based delivery driver. With the English economy having flatlined, the Bankrupt are forced to carry out menial tasks for the Loaded to make ends meet, and a missed coffee-drop can be the difference between a bed for the night and going hungry. But when a redundant librarian offers to pay off Amir's health insurance debts in return for a delivering a mystery package, liberty and creative endeavour are cruelly compromised by political and socioeconomic reality.

Micaiah Holman's entertaining second novel, Nemesis (Hodder & Stoughton, £14.99), opens with an announcement by the WHO that a successful coronavirus vaccine has been discovered. But even as the world celebrates, an unprecedented iceberg calving event causes the Gulf Stream to accelerate sparking methane plumes across the Arctic and setting in train an irreversible surge in global sea level, plunging the population back into unmitigated despair as they realise things are never going to get any better and 2019 was as good as it ever gets. Without offering too many spoilers, Ms Holman will not be writing a follow-up novel.

Family troubles drive the plot of author Kit Percher's latest release, Stay Indoors (Vertigo, £9.99). Set in an unnamed suburb where a global pandemic has confined citizens to their homes, Jean and Ken spend their days watching TV, surreptitiously tending to their garden and waiting for the weekly grocery drone-drop. But when the internet fails and Radio 2 goes silent, the couple are forced to talk to each other over what's left of the coffee, opening up long-buried wounds. As the power cuts become more persistent and the sudokus run out, the race is on to settle old scores before hypothermia sets in.

In Last Christmas (Random House, £11.99), an exciting collaboration between Elizabeth Kay and Caitlin Lam, the nation's festivities are disrupted by a cavalcade of calamities. On the first day red tape at the Channel ports prevent delivery of Yuletide essentials, on the second day a global stock market crash wipes out the banking system and on the third day an additional coronavirus is discovered and runs rampant across the Home Counties. By the time the aliens land on day six the tension has been ratcheted up to unbearable levels, and in the end humanity's fate is a toss up between a solar flare and an unexpected meteor strike. The ideal uplifting 2020 stocking filler.

Presidential quiz
Here are clues to the surnames of 29 US Presidents and one President-Elect.
How many can you name?

definition
  1) fart
  2) allow
  3) shrub
  4) biscuit
  5) vacuum
  6) puncture
  7) card shop
  8) cartoon cat
  9) cross stream
10) Lower Teesdale     
anagram
11) crater
12) ran age
13) airhorns
14) domains
15) more on
16) dice logo
17) my nickel
18) to resolve
19) brave nun
20) we heroines       
cryptic
21) cram extra
22) wait (noun)
23) sounds misty
24) 9 in negative
25) spirit in brown
26) heavy laundry
27) endless dance
28) thanks newspaper
29) back in ham about
30) Lovelace manuscript

All now guessed, thanks. Answers in the comments box.

20 things that happened this week #coronavirus

• Test and Trace app set threshold too high
• England lockdown 'may last more than 4 weeks'
• Prince William contracted virus in April
• increased help for the self-employed
• lockdown a 'medical and moral' responsibility (PM)
• everyone in Liverpool to be tested
• UK death rate 10% higher than usual
• shops extend hours/pubs offload beer
• US election - outcome unclear
• M&S suffers first annual loss
• 38 MPs vote against lockdown 2
• Lockdown for four weeks across England
• furlough scheme extended until March
• new rapid test misses half of cases
• Danish mink hosted virus mutation
• Denmark/Sweden/Germany → quarantine list
• infection rate may be stabilising
• UK bans visitors from Denmark
• St Paul's Cathedral gets £2m culture grant
• Joe Biden announced as US president

Worldwide deaths: 1,180,000 → 1,250,000
Worldwide cases: 45,800,000 → 49,600,000
UK deaths: 46,555 → 48,888
UK cases: 1,011,660 → 1,171,441
FTSE: up 6% (5577 → 5910)

 Saturday, November 07, 2020

Anorak Corner [DLR/Overground/Crossrail edition]

For the first time, TfL's latest splurge of passenger data also includes official entry and exit data for stations on the Docklands Light Railway, London Overground and TfL Rail. Figures are for total entries and exits during the calendar year 2019.

The DLR's ten busiest stations (2019) (with changes since 2018)
  1) Bank (30m)
  2)
Canary Wharf (18m)
  3)
Woolwich Arsenal (15m)
  4)
Canning Town (14m)
  5)
↑1 Stratford (10.5m)
  6)
↑1 Limehouse (9.8m)
  7)
↓2 Lewisham (9.7m)
  8)
Shadwell (8.9m)
  9)
Heron Quays (8.2m)
10)
Cutty Sark (7.1m)

Bank is the most used DLR station, which is good going for two cramped platforms shoehorned under the City of London. Tower Gateway is 14th, for comparison. In second place is Canary Wharf, the line's other financial nexus. Woolwich Arsenal takes third place, confirming the wisdom of driving a DLR extension under the river. Canning Town's total includes all those interchanging to/from the Jubilee line. Stratford's DLR passenger numbers continue to edge up while Lewisham's are falling back. Cutty Sark is the highest ranked DLR station not to interchange with any other railway line.

The DLR's ten least busy stations (2019)
  1) Beckton Park (509000)
  2)
Pudding Mill Lane (856000)
  3)
Stratford High Street (1.18m)
  4)
Abbey Road (1.22m)
  5)
West India Quay (1.31m)
  6)
Gallions Reach (1.42m)
  7)
Star Lane (1.50m)
  8)
Elverson Road (1.70m)
  9)
↑1 Royal Albert (1.82m)
10)
↓1 King George V (1.86m)

Beckton Park, three stops before Beckton, remains the least used DLR station. Pudding Mill Lane is the other DLR station with fewer than a million passengers annually (despite having been rebuilt as the largest station on the network). Stratford High Street, Abbey Road and Star Lane are all on the Stratford International branch, bypassed by the Jubilee line, and not especially busy. Most of the least used stations are on the fringes of Newham, with Elverson Road the only straggler south of the river. Pontoon Dock was in this Bottom 10 two years ago but is no longer in the Bottom 20 thanks to the development of dense new housing alongside.

The Overground's ten busiest stations (2019) (with changes since 2018)
  1) ↑1 Highbury & Islington (23.6m)
  2)
↓1 Canada Water (23.4m)
  3)
Stratford (16.0m)
  4)
Clapham Junction (14.8m)
  5)
Whitechapel (14.0m)
  6)
Liverpool Street (13.4m)
  7)
Willesden Junction (10.6m)
  8)
↑1 Shoreditch High Street (9.5m)
  9)
↓1 Seven Sisters (9.4m)
10)
Shepherd's Bush (8.3m)

Highbury & Islington creeps into first position ahead of previous champion Canada Water, but only just. Both stations benefit from interchanges with busy tube lines. At Stratford more people catch the Overground than catch the DLR. Clapham Junction's 15m is perhaps half of all those who enter and exit the station annually. Shoreditch High Street is the only station in the Top 10 to be Overground only.

The Overground's ten least busy stations (2019)
  1) Battersea Park (12200)
  2)
Emerson Park (323000)
  3)
Cheshunt (459000)
  4)
↑3 North Wembley (550000)
  5)
↑1 South Kenton (561000)
  6)
↓2 South Hampstead (577000)
  7)
↓2 Upminster (596000)
  8)
Romford (638000)
  9)
Headstone Lane (653000)
10)
Bushey (699000)

The Overground's least used station is the one hardly any trains stop at. Battersea Park sees only two Overground departures and one Overground arrival a day, so attracts barely 40 passengers a day. Far more worthy of the title is Emerson Park, the least-used regularly-served station, which averages more like 1000. Cheshunt appears because it has much faster non-orange trains to central London, ditto Bushey. Figures suggest that quarter of North Wembley and South Kenton's passengers take the Overground while the rest take the Bakerloo. Upminster and Romford are very busy stations where the Overground is an insignificant part of overall traffic.

TfL Rail's ten busiest stations (2019) (with changes since 2018)
  1) Stratford (27m)
  2)
Liverpool Street (19m)
  3)
↑1 Romford (8.9m)
  4)
↓1 Ilford (8.3m)
  5)
Paddington (4.7m)
  6)
Chadwell Heath (4.4m)
  7)
Goodmayes (4.0m)
  8)
Forest Gate (3.9m)
  9)
Seven Kings (3.5m)
10)
↑1 Harold Wood (3.1m)

One day this will be a Crossrail list, but for now it's mainly a measure of the popularity of suburban stations between Liverpool Street and Shenfield. Stratford and Liverpool Street dominate, both far in advance of Romford and Ilford, which themselves easily outrank everywhere else. Paddington is the only western station to feature. Stations from West Drayton to Reading are not included because they only joined TfL Rail in December 2019.

TfL Rail's ten least busy stations (2019)
  1) Acton Main Line (381000)
  2)
Hanwell (676000)
  3)
↑2 Heathrow T4 (1.43m)
  4)
West Ealing (1.49m)
  5)
↓2 Maryland (1.56m)
  6)
Heathrow T2&3 (1.66m)
  7)
Shenfield (1.86m)
  8)
↑6 Brentwood (2.43m)
  9)
↑1 Hayes & Harlington (2.55m)
10)
↓2 Southall (2.56m)

Most of these lesser used stations are to the west of London, headed by currently insignificant halts at Acton and Hanwell. Heathrow is not (yet) a significant driver of TfL Rail services. Maryland is the only underperforming station to the east of the capital, along with Shenfield and Brentwood just outside. Anorak Corner 2023 is likely to bring lowly Twyford, Taplow and Iver to this list, but for now just revel in the sheer unnecessariness of it all.

Finally, because TfL are now producing data for tube, DLR, Overground and TfL stations on an equal footing, I can bring you this definitive ranking...

TfL's ten least busy stations (2019)
  1) Emerson Park (323000) [Overground]
  2)
Acton Main Line (381000) [TfL Rail]
  3)
Roding Valley (450000) [Tube]
  4)
Beckton Park (509000) [DLR]
  5)
Chigwell (525000) [Tube]
  6)
South Hampstead (577000) [Overground]
  7)
Grange Hill (652000) [Tube]
  8)
Headstone Lane (653000) [Overground]
  9)
Hanwell (676000) [TfL Rail]
10)
Hatch End (726000) [Overground]

I've excluded stations served by more than one mode, because their combined passenger totals are too large, so these genuinely are TfL's least used stations. I like how each of the four modes appears in the list, indeed numbers 1-4 include one of each! Emerson Park takes the tumbleweed award, and rightly so, followed by empty Acton Main Line and lowly Roding Valley. If London's National Rail stations were allowed to compete they'd take all ten places... and the next ten after that. And if only TfL had thrown in totals for tram stops then I could have brought you the Tube Map's Least Used Top 10, but hey, maybe next year.

 Friday, November 06, 2020

Anorak Corner (the annual update) [tube edition]

Hurrah, it's that time of year again when TfL silently updates its spreadsheet of total annual passenger numbers at every tube station.

London's ten busiest tube stations (2019) (with changes since 2018)
  1) King's Cross St Pancras (88.3m)
  2)
Victoria (85.5m)
  3)
Waterloo (82.9m)
  4)
Oxford Circus (78.1m)
  5)
London Bridge (74.3m)
  6)
Liverpool Street (67.2m)
  7)
Stratford (64.9m)
  8)
Bank/Monument (61.8m)
  9) ↑1 Paddington (48.6m)
10)
↓1 Canary Wharf (47.7m)

King's Cross St Pancras retains its crown as London's busiest tube station, a title it's held since 2017, by attracting 88 million passengers last year. Previous champions Victoria and Waterloo are close behind. Central London rail termini take most of the top positions, with Oxford Circus a rare West End outlier. Out east it's Stratford which dominates, boasting more than twice as many passengers as it had ten years ago. The only stations to have changed places since last year are Paddington and Canary Wharf, indeed Canary Wharf is the only station in the Top 10 to have lost passengers. 2020's data will no doubt show something entirely different, so 2019's ranking is a last hurrah for what normality used to look like.

London's ten busiest tube stations that aren't also National Rail stations (2019)
  1) Oxford Circus (78.1m)
  2)
Bank/Monument (61.8m)
  3)
Canary Wharf (47.7m)
  4)
Tottenham Court Road (42.0m)
  5)
Green Park (39.1m)
  6)
↑1 Piccadilly Circus (38.4m)
  7)
↓1 Bond Street (37.5m)
  8)
Leicester Square (34.6m)
  9)
South Kensington (33.1m)
10)
↑1 Brixton (32.0m)

The top five tube-only stations have remained static over the last twelve months, below which Piccadilly Circus successfully leapfrogs Bond Street. The majority of these ten non-rail stations are at the heart of the West End, delivering millions of Londoners to the shops and to work. Canary Wharf is the busiest station on just one line, keeping the whole of Docklands ticking over, while South Kensington confirms the pulling power of the museums. Meanwhile Brixton has added an extra two million passengers to return to the Top 10, nudging out longstanding Holborn.

London's ten busiest tube stations outside Zone 2 (2019)
  1) ↑2 Walthamstow Central (18.9m)
  2) Barking (18.1m)
  3) ↓2 Seven Sisters (17.0m)
  4) Ealing Broadway (16.1m)
  5) ↑1 Tooting Broadway (15.43m)
  6) ↓1 Wembley Park (15.42m)
  7) ↑1 Tottenham Hale (14.0m)
  8) ↑1 Balham (13.1m)
  9) ↓2 East Ham (13.0m)
10) Wimbledon (12.5m)

It's all change beyond zone 2 as Walthamstow Central snatches pole position. Its passenger numbers are up 10% since 2018, one of the largest increases of any tube station, while further down the Victoria line Seven Sisters has dropped back. East Ham's fall is another consequence of a drop in passengers, whereas the swap between 5th and 6th is a statistical technicality. A number of these non-central hotspots are at interchanges with other railway lines, with Tooting Broadway the highest-placed tube-only station. If the list were to continue then Harrow-on-the-Hill (11m) would be the highest performing station in Zone 5 and Uxbridge (8m) the busiest in Zone 6.

And now for my favourite list of the year...

London's 10 least busy tube stations (2019)
  1) Kensington (Olympia) (109000)
  2) Roding Valley (450000)
  3) Chigwell (525000)
  4) Grange Hill (652000)
  5) North Ealing (880000)
  6) Theydon Bois (896000)
  7) Moor Park (933000)
  8) Ruislip Gardens (1107000)
  9) ↑3 Upminster Bridge (1108000)
10) ↑1 Ickenham (1119000)

The least used station on the Underground remains poor old Kensington (Olympia), because that's what weekend-only trains (and a tiny handful of weekday-ers) does for you. It has a pitiful total... less than a quarter of the passengers at the second least used station, which continues to be Roding Valley. Indeed the Essex end of the Central line has a strong showing here, including all three stops on the Hainault shuttle. Two years ago four Metropolitan line stations outside London would have made an appearance, but Moor Park is now the only one left. Meanwhile North Ealing (zone 3), Ruislip Gardens (zone 5) and Upminster Bridge (zone 6) all lose out by having more popular stations close by.

The next ten least busy stations: Croxley, Chesham, Fairlop, West Harrow, Mill Hill East, South Kenton, Chorleywood, West Ruislip, North Wembley, Barkingside

Full datasets
» Tube passenger data can be found here (total annual entry and exit frequencies)
» For the annual rail passenger data update, see January's post

(and if you're thinking hang on, I thought Roding Valley was the least used tube station, I need to apologise...)



Anorak Corner (an apology)

Anorak Corner has been a regular annual feature on this blog since 2007. But if you've been paying attention you may have noticed I haven't published a tube update for well over two years, in fact not since June 2018.

TfL normally slip out an updated spreadsheet in the spring, but in spring 2019 absolutely nothing happened. I've been keeping an eye on the relevant page on the TfL website ever since, which is the best part of eighteen months, but the data's never changed. Then last week, to my surprise, the spreadsheet disappeared. The webpage is now solely a repository of dull monthly metrics and the annual station usage statistics have been withdrawn.

This seemed odd because TfL had promised earlier in the year that the station usage data would be published. An FoI request in March received the response that "2018 and 2019 data will be available at the end of March 2020", but then lockdown happened and it wasn't. Anorak Corner was on hold.

Thankfully another set of data appears to have slipped out in its place. TfL have a website called crowding.data.tfl.gov.uk where they publish detailed open data sets for the benefit of app developers and other statistical folk. A folder called Annual Station Counts was added in June, followed in September by spreadsheets AnnualisedEntryExit_2017.xlsx, AnnualisedEntryExit_2018.xlsx and AnnualisedEntryExit_2019.xlsx. These look very much like the old data but in technicolour, so hurrah, Anorak Corner is back on.

But the numbers don't quite match up. The new 2017 spreadsheet has different totals to the original 2017 spreadsheet, in every case about 5% lower, suggesting there's been a change in how the results are calculated. The difference is roughly equivalent to losing two weeks' worth of passengers. This means New Anorak Corner won't quite align with Old Anorak Corner, although the rankings generally haven't changed.

The 2018 spreadsheet then introduced another change. Almost all the entry and exit numbers are calculated from gateline data, but at three stations they're now based on boarding/alighting surveys instead. This hasn't made much of a difference at Richmond and Wimbledon but it's had a dramatic effect at Kensington (Olympia). The station's 2017 total had been 1,856,000 but its 2018 total was only 111,000 - a staggering decrease of 94%. Stripping out Overground users means a much better match to actual passenger numbers, but also suggests several previous years of data were very wrong.

I've based this year's Anorak Corner on the 2019 spreadsheet. This follows the updated method of measuring passenger numbers so is the new definitive standard. But it appears I've been telling you a lie for years regarding the tube's least used station. It's not Roding Valley, it's Kensington (Olympia), as should have been self-evident from the pitiful number of trains it gets. Please take all the other figures in this year's Anorak Corner with a suitable margin of scepticism. New Methodology, New Anorak Corner.

 Thursday, November 05, 2020

Lockdown 2 is not the same as Lockdown 1. Schools are open, the weather's worse and the rules on travel are subtly different.

But do you know what the rules on travel actually are? I ask because they keep changing, indeed they've been updated twice since the weekend.

Here's what the travel guidance said on Saturday after the Prime Minister's announcement.



The key message was to avoid "non-essential travel", which is much the same message as in the spring. The definition of essential travel was then spelled out for those whose common sense failed to match expectations.

But only non-essential travel by private and public transport was specifically restricted. Essential shopping wasn't defined. Exercise wasn't mentioned. And although we were being asked to avoid all non-essential travel, the list of reasons provided was preceded by "includes, but is not limited to". On the surface it seemed over-restrictive, but in reality it was anything but.

There was also a request to "reduce the number of journeys you make", without making it clear precisely what a journey was or over what period the reduction should be made. Did they mean journeys by private and public transport only, and making fewer than before, or did they mean leaving the house less often by whatever means?

Anyway forget that because they changed it. Here's what the travel guidance said on Sunday after a significant tweak.



The word 'essential' had entirely vanished. The concept of a local area had appeared. Travel to any open venue was now permitted. And exercise was now fine so long as you only needed a short journey to get there. But by rewording the text to clarify certain aspects of the guidance, further ambiguities had been introduced.

For a start, what precisely was a 'local area'? Was it administratively-based, for example a county or a borough, because that can be really problematic for anyone living on the border. Was it perhaps distance-related, as when Wales introduced a requirement earlier this year to stay within five miles of home. Or was this a good old woolly compromise, hinting that long jaunts across country weren't acceptable whereas a brief drive across town was fine. In a country as geographically varied as England something vague was probably the way to go.

Distance reared its awkward head again in relation to exercise, where this was now only OK if it required a 'short journey'. Was this about keeping cycle jaunts and walking trips down to a reasonable length rather than spending several hours outdoors? Or was it recognition that you might have to use transport to reach a park or recreational space and so to go to a local one rather than driving miles across country?

Anyway forget that because they changed it again. Here's what the travel guidance said yesterday after a significant tweak.



'Local areas' and 'short journeys' have now vanished, removing any ambiguity over what those phrases actually meant. But the opening line is now much more hard-hitting, suggesting "you cannot travel within the UK"! It's OK, an extended list of sensible exceptions follows, but the overarching tone seems a lot more restrictive than before.

Travel for work is fine if you absolutely have to. Travel for education, health or care is fine, as is jetting off to see the rest of your bubble. Travel for buying any goods or services is now explicitly OK, just so long as the premises are open...

...and travel for exercise has been significantly altered. Exercise now should take place 'locally wherever possible', which revisits the thorny definition of localness and also opens up the possibility of exercising elsewhere. But does 'wherever possible' mean you shouldn't go to your second nearest park, only the closest to home, or is it more about stopping people driving to distant woodland or the seaside for no good reason?

It's worth pointing out that the underlying legislation, published on Tuesday, hasn't changed. It's especially worth pointing out that this legislation doesn't list any travel restrictions whatsoever - everything is framed according to whether or not you have an acceptable reason to leave your home. All these supposed travel restrictions are in fact nothing more than guidance. The police should only be interested in where you're going and why, not how far you've come.

This lockdown travel guidance is somewhat vague, I bet, because we're all of us in very different circumstances. A family in the Lake District needs to read it and find relevance to their own situation, as does a student in Nottingham or a pensioner in Wembley. We all have to be persuaded to do the right thing, even when that right thing isn't tightly defined in law.

Anyway don't get too hung up on the fine detail because you can bet only a tiny proportion of the population have read it. More importantly the rules will probably have changed again by next week, as yet another attempt to make things clearer only serves to muddy the waters. Best stay at home.

Friday update: It's changed again. "If you live in England, you must stay at home and avoid travel in the UK or overseas, unless..."

 Wednesday, November 04, 2020

Where's your nearest public footpath?

I ask because I checked and I was very surprised, and then I checked my second nearest and I was amazed.

A lot of this comes down to definitions. Footpaths are everywhere - between buildings, through woods, across fields - but only some are officially classified as Public Rights of Way. These are paths on which the public have a legally protected right to pass, and have to be designated as such by local councils through inclusion on a definitive map. Some unrecorded routes may also be public paths through common usage, but for today's post I can only consider those appearing on council maps. Let's start closest to home...

Tower Hamlets

There are no public rights of way in Tower Hamlets. The National Parks and Access to the Countryside Act 1949 exempted London on the basis that it was overwhelmingly built-up land, an exemption which still applies to the 12 Inner London boroughs. If you check an Ordnance Survey you'll see it's true, there are no red dashed lines anywhere from Camden to Greenwich or Woolwich to Hackney. A campaign was started in 2010 to get the Inner London boroughs to produce their own Definitive Rights of Way Map but none have yet done so. This doesn't stop anyone walking up an alleyway or crossing a recreation ground, of course, but to track down an official public right of way I need to go to Outer London...

Newham

Newham has a Definitive Rights of Way Map, and better still has an interactive map on its website to show them all. This confirms that a lot of the paths I thought might be public rights of way actually aren't. The River Lea towpath is a permissive path. The Greenway is a permissive path. We walk along them thanks to the goodwill of the owner, which in the Greenway's case is Thames Water, who technically could withdraw access rights at any time. But I did spot a genuine public right of way less than half a mile from my home and it's here...



This is Three Mills, the tidal mill on the Lea, and a splendid place for a walk. But the public right of way isn't a riverside stroll, it's just this short run of cobbles which took me precisely one minute to complete. The public footpath starts halfway across the footbridge, because the other side is in Tower Hamlets where public rights of way don't exist. It continues above the millrace between the House Mill and the Clock Mill, then stops suddenly outside the entrance to Three Mills Studios. Here it meets the permissive path round the outside of the studio complex... which has been stopped up since March 2007, which just goes to show how easy it is to lose access to an unprotected path.

This 100 metre tiddler is my nearest public footpath. Ridiculous. But when I scoured Newham's map further I really struggled to find red dotted public rights of way, only green Permissive Paths and purple Other Routes (publicly maintained). Nothing in Stratford, nothing in the Olympic Park, nothing in Forest Gate, Plaistow or Canning Town. Eventually I spotted another one over by City Airport, and had to double check the map to confirm I wasn't seeing things. My second closest public right of way is here...



This is Connaught Bridge, a crossing point between the Royal Victoria and Royal Albert Dock. Pedestrians aren't welcome on the overpass so an alternative route exists at dockside level. The public footpath starts beside the end of the runway, close to a Caution Jet Blast sign, then ducks under the concrete roadway and crosses a cantilever footbridge. Fabulous view of Docklands at the far end of the water! But the public footpath then meanders along a hatched service road outside the DoubleTree Hotel, miserably overseen by Private No Parking signs, before passing the Premier Inn and stopping dead outside the Fox@Connaught. It took me barely four minutes to walk it end to end. It could hardly feel less like a public footpath if it tried.

Checking the map, it appears that Newham has only four other public rights of way.



• One's along the Thames foreshore facing Gallions Reach, a formerly desolate outpost now being overshadowed by flats. If you've ever walked the last section of the Capital Ring you'll have walked this way.
• A second runs alongside Langdon Academy playing fields and ends up beside a grim embankment on the North Circular. I've only walked it once, and let's just say I quickened my pace.
• A third cuts between the sheds on Beckton Triangle Retail Park, first alongside Harveys then across the car park to PC World. Fifty years ago this was Gooseley Lane, but there's no modern excuse.
• Finally a much longer public footpath exists around three sides of the City of London Cemetery in Aldersbrook. One side is part of the Roding Valley Way. I have never built up the confidence to walk down it.

Newham's six public footpaths, to be frank, are monumentally underwhelming. But they're still better than...

Waltham Forest

Although councils were supposed to have a Definitive Rights of Way Map in 2008, Waltham Forest missed the target. They managed a Rights of Way Improvement Plan, but this mostly recognised a series of action points without an actual outcome. One issue is that the three boroughs which merged to form Waltham Forest had very different footpath legacies. Walthamstow recorded 111, Chingford two and Leyton none at all ("There are no routes recorded for this area as it was considered to be so fully developed as to make a survey inexpedient"). It reads as if Waltham Forest put their predecessor's plans in a drawer and forgot about them.

Waltham Forest's RoWIP mentions that the borough now has 15 PRoWs, but doesn't mention where they are. No official map has ever been published. In 2017 a resident tried to extract the list in a Freedom of Information request, but all the Information Officer could say was "Public Rights of Way data referred to is recorded and retained in paper and PDF (extracts) format only at time of writing. Such data can be made available - by prior request - at any of the borough's libraries of offices." For all I know my second nearest public footpath is in Waltham Forest, but I have no easy way to tell.

And all this matter because a race is on. The Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000 decreed that any pre-1949 footpaths not recorded on official maps on 1st January 2026 would cease to carry public rights and could be stopped up. The Ramblers Association has been running a lengthy campaign to hunt down England's missing footpaths, with lockdown giving local research a bit of a boost, but several thousand miles remain at risk. Some of those might well be in Waltham Forest, but who's to know?

Redbridge

Redbridge has an exemplary public footpath record. It has a plan, a Definitive Map and an interactive map on its website with all 160 public rights of way shown and summarised. I even used it once to write a particularly niche blogpost about five Ilford footpaths, it's that comprehensive. If I lived in Redbridge I'd know precisely where to walk.

But within three miles of my home, to my knowledge, there are only two public rights of way and they're both highly disappointing. I hope your nearest footpath, wherever it is, inspires you more.


<< click for Newer posts

click for Older Posts >>


click to return to the main page


...or read more in my monthly archives
Jan26  Feb26  Mar26  Apr26  May26  Jun26  Jul26  Aug26  Sep26  Oct26  Nov26
Jan25  Feb25  Mar25  Apr25  May25  Jun25  Jul25  Aug25  Sep25  Oct25  Nov25  Dec25
Jan24  Feb24  Mar24  Apr24  May24  Jun24  Jul24  Aug24  Sep24  Oct24  Nov24  Dec24
Jan23  Feb23  Mar23  Apr23  May23  Jun23  Jul23  Aug23  Sep23  Oct23  Nov23  Dec23
Jan22  Feb22  Mar22  Apr22  May22  Jun22  Jul22  Aug22  Sep22  Oct22  Nov22  Dec22
Jan21  Feb21  Mar21  Apr21  May21  Jun21  Jul21  Aug21  Sep21  Oct21  Nov21  Dec21
Jan20  Feb20  Mar20  Apr20  May20  Jun20  Jul20  Aug20  Sep20  Oct20  Nov20  Dec20
Jan19  Feb19  Mar19  Apr19  May19  Jun19  Jul19  Aug19  Sep19  Oct19  Nov19  Dec19
Jan18  Feb18  Mar18  Apr18  May18  Jun18  Jul18  Aug18  Sep18  Oct18  Nov18  Dec18
Jan17  Feb17  Mar17  Apr17  May17  Jun17  Jul17  Aug17  Sep17  Oct17  Nov17  Dec17
Jan16  Feb16  Mar16  Apr16  May16  Jun16  Jul16  Aug16  Sep16  Oct16  Nov16  Dec16
Jan15  Feb15  Mar15  Apr15  May15  Jun15  Jul15  Aug15  Sep15  Oct15  Nov15  Dec15
Jan14  Feb14  Mar14  Apr14  May14  Jun14  Jul14  Aug14  Sep14  Oct14  Nov14  Dec14
Jan13  Feb13  Mar13  Apr13  May13  Jun13  Jul13  Aug13  Sep13  Oct13  Nov13  Dec13
Jan12  Feb12  Mar12  Apr12  May12  Jun12  Jul12  Aug12  Sep12  Oct12  Nov12  Dec12
Jan11  Feb11  Mar11  Apr11  May11  Jun11  Jul11  Aug11  Sep11  Oct11  Nov11  Dec11
Jan10  Feb10  Mar10  Apr10  May10  Jun10  Jul10  Aug10  Sep10  Oct10  Nov10  Dec10
Jan09  Feb09  Mar09  Apr09  May09  Jun09  Jul09  Aug09  Sep09  Oct09  Nov09  Dec09
Jan08  Feb08  Mar08  Apr08  May08  Jun08  Jul08  Aug08  Sep08  Oct08  Nov08  Dec08
Jan07  Feb07  Mar07  Apr07  May07  Jun07  Jul07  Aug07  Sep07  Oct07  Nov07  Dec07
Jan06  Feb06  Mar06  Apr06  May06  Jun06  Jul06  Aug06  Sep06  Oct06  Nov06  Dec06
Jan05  Feb05  Mar05  Apr05  May05  Jun05  Jul05  Aug05  Sep05  Oct05  Nov05  Dec05
Jan04  Feb04  Mar04  Apr04  May04  Jun04  Jul04  Aug04  Sep04  Oct04  Nov04  Dec04
Jan03  Feb03  Mar03  Apr03  May03  Jun03  Jul03  Aug03  Sep03  Oct03  Nov03  Dec03
 Jan02  Feb02  Mar02  Apr02  May02  Jun02  Jul02 Aug02  Sep02  Oct02  Nov02  Dec02 
















jack of diamonds
Life viewed from London E3

» email me
» follow me on twitter
» follow the blog on twitter
» follow the blog on Bluesky
» follow the blog on RSS

» my flickr photostream

twenty blogs
our bow
arseblog
ian visits
londonist
on london
blue witch
the great wen
london centric
edith's streets
spitalfields life
fifteensquared
linkmachinego
round the island
wanstead meteo
christopher fowler
bus and train user
ruth's coastal walk
the greenwich wire
round the rails we go
london reconnections

quick reference features
Things to do in Outer London
Things to do outside London
London's waymarked walks
Inner London toilet map
20 years of blog series
The DG Tour of Britain
London's most...

read the archive
Nov26  Oct26  Sep26
Aug26  Jul26  Jun26  May26
Apr26  Mar26  Feb26  Jan26
Dec25  Nov25  Oct25  Sep25
Aug25  Jul25  Jun25  May25
Apr25  Mar25  Feb25  Jan25
Dec24  Nov24  Oct24  Sep24
Aug24  Jul24  Jun24  May24
Apr24  Mar24  Feb24  Jan24
Dec23  Nov23  Oct23  Sep23
Aug23  Jul23  Jun23  May23
Apr23  Mar23  Feb23  Jan23
Dec22  Nov22  Oct22  Sep22
Aug22  Jul22  Jun22  May22
Apr22  Mar22  Feb22  Jan22
Dec21  Nov21  Oct21  Sep21
Aug21  Jul21  Jun21  May21
Apr21  Mar21  Feb21  Jan21
Dec20  Nov20  Oct20  Sep20
Aug20  Jul20  Jun20  May20
Apr20  Mar20  Feb20  Jan20
Dec19  Nov19  Oct19  Sep19
Aug19  Jul19  Jun19  May19
Apr19  Mar19  Feb19  Jan19
Dec18  Nov18  Oct18  Sep18
Aug18  Jul18  Jun18  May18
Apr18  Mar18  Feb18  Jan18
Dec17  Nov17  Oct17  Sep17
Aug17  Jul17  Jun17  May17
Apr17  Mar17  Feb17  Jan17
Dec16  Nov16  Oct16  Sep16
Aug16  Jul16  Jun16  May16
Apr16  Mar16  Feb16  Jan16
Dec15  Nov15  Oct15  Sep15
Aug15  Jul15  Jun15  May15
Apr15  Mar15  Feb15  Jan15
Dec14  Nov14  Oct14  Sep14
Aug14  Jul14  Jun14  May14
Apr14  Mar14  Feb14  Jan14
Dec13  Nov13  Oct13  Sep13
Aug13  Jul13  Jun13  May13
Apr13  Mar13  Feb13  Jan13
Dec12  Nov12  Oct12  Sep12
Aug12  Jul12  Jun12  May12
Apr12  Mar12  Feb12  Jan12
Dec11  Nov11  Oct11  Sep11
Aug11  Jul11  Jun11  May11
Apr11  Mar11  Feb11  Jan11
Dec10  Nov10  Oct10  Sep10
Aug10  Jul10  Jun10  May10
Apr10  Mar10  Feb10  Jan10
Dec09  Nov09  Oct09  Sep09
Aug09  Jul09  Jun09  May09
Apr09  Mar09  Feb09  Jan09
Dec08  Nov08  Oct08  Sep08
Aug08  Jul08  Jun08  May08
Apr08  Mar08  Feb08  Jan08
Dec07  Nov07  Oct07  Sep07
Aug07  Jul07  Jun07  May07
Apr07  Mar07  Feb07  Jan07
Dec06  Nov06  Oct06  Sep06
Aug06  Jul06  Jun06  May06
Apr06  Mar06  Feb06  Jan06
Dec05  Nov05  Oct05  Sep05
Aug05  Jul05  Jun05  May05
Apr05  Mar05  Feb05  Jan05
Dec04  Nov04  Oct04  Sep04
Aug04  Jul04  Jun04  May04
Apr04  Mar04  Feb04  Jan04
Dec03  Nov03  Oct03  Sep03
Aug03  Jul03  Jun03  May03
Apr03  Mar03  Feb03  Jan03
Dec02  Nov02  Oct02  Sep02
back to main page

the diamond geezer index
2025 2024 2023 2022
2021 2020 2019 2018 2017
2016 2015 2014 2013 2012
2011 2010 2009 2008 2007
2006 2005 2004 2003 2002

my special London features
a-z of london museums
E3 - local history month
greenwich meridian (N)
greenwich meridian (S)
the real eastenders
london's lost rivers
olympic park 2007
great british roads
oranges & lemons
random boroughs
bow road station
high street 2012
river westbourne
trafalgar square
capital numbers
east london line
lea valley walk
olympics 2005
regent's canal
square routes
silver jubilee
unlost rivers
cube routes
Herbert Dip
metro-land
capital ring
river fleet
piccadilly
bakerloo

ten of my favourite posts
the seven ages of blog
my new Z470xi mobile
five equations of blog
the dome of doom
chemical attraction
quality & risk
london 2102
single life
boredom
april fool

ten sets of lovely photos
my "most interesting" photos
london 2012 olympic zone
harris and the hebrides
betjeman's metro-land
marking the meridian
tracing the river fleet
london's lost rivers
inside the gherkin
seven sisters
iceland

just surfed in?
here's where to find...
diamond geezers
flash mob #1  #2  #3  #4
ben schott's miscellany
london underground
watch with mother
cigarette warnings
digital time delay
wheelie suitcases
war of the worlds
transit of venus
top of the pops
old buckenham
ladybird books
acorn antiques
digital watches
outer hebrides
olympics 2012
school dinners
pet shop boys
west wycombe
bletchley park
george orwell
big breakfast
clapton pond
san francisco
thunderbirds
routemaster
children's tv
east enders
trunk roads
amsterdam
little britain
credit cards
jury service
big brother
jubilee line
number 1s
titan arum
typewriters
doctor who
coronation
comments
blue peter
matchgirls
hurricanes
buzzwords
brookside
monopoly
peter pan
starbucks
feng shui
leap year
manbags
bbc three
vision on
piccadilly
meridian
concorde
wembley
islington
ID cards
bedtime
freeview
beckton
blogads
eclipses
letraset
arsenal
sitcoms
gherkin
calories
everest
muffins
sudoku
camilla
london
ceefax
robbie
becks
dome
BBC2
paris
lotto
118
itv